An Open Letter to President Obama From the Wife of Convicted Whistleblower
Jeffrey Sterling
http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/an_open_letter_to_president_obama_from_t
he_wife_of_20151016/
Posted on Oct 16, 2015
By Holly Sterling
Former CIA officer Jeffrey Sterling, center, accompanied by his wife,
Holly, departs federal court in Alexandria, Va., in May. (Andrew Harnik /
AP)
Editors note: Earlier this year, former CIA officer and whistleblower
Jeffrey Sterling was convicted under the Espionage Act of leaking
information to New York Times reporter James Risen and sentenced to 3½ years
in prison. In the letter below, Sterlings wife appeals to President Obama
for an immediate pardon for her husband.
President Barack Obama
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Ave, NW
Washington, DC 20500
October 15, 2015
Dear Mr. President,
I am writing you on behalf of my innocent husband Mr. Jeffrey Alexander
Sterling. You know Mr. Sterling as the former disgruntled CIA Officer that
your administration indicted and prosecuted, resulting in conviction on nine
felony counts, seven of them under the antiquated Espionage Act, with a
sentence of three and a half years in prison. I would like to introduce you
to the real Jeffrey Sterling who is my best friend and husband for the past
11 years.
Jeffrey Sterling was born and raised in Cape Girardeau, Missouri. He is the
youngest of six boys, and his parents divorced at a very early age. Jeffrey
was a very inquisitive, bright, and driven child. He once took apart his
mothers radio just to see the interior working mechanisms and as a
challenge to be able to reassemble it in working order. As a young boy, he
would spend every Friday evening with his maternal grandmother visiting,
watching their beloved Cardinals baseball team, or assisting her around her
home.
Even at a young age, Jeffrey had a very strong moral code of ethics.
Jeffreys cousin, Darian Martin, fondly recollects Jeffrey as always being
like a big brother to me. I always looked up to Jeff because he was
extremely talented. He was an artist, musician, a writer, and was also an
outstanding athlete to name a few of his qualities. Jeff also spent time
with me and 2 our other cousins and instilled discipline in our lives. He is
truly a role model and one of the most successful members of our family.
Jeff has always been an honest person and has always made excellent
decisions. Jeff gave me hope that I could grow up and be someone, and that
is exactly what I have done by walking in his footsteps.
Jeffrey enjoyed and excelled at academics and knew from an early age he
would attend college; as it turned out he was the only one of his siblings
to do so. After graduating from high school, Jeffrey attended Millikin
University and pursued a political science degree. During his schooling, he
became a member of the Tau Kappa Epsilon Fraternity where he met and
befriended current Commander William Roth of the United States Navy Reserve
Component. Mr. Roth describes Jeffrey as selfless, he regularly put the
needs and wants of others ahead of his own. Mr. Roth recalled a Sunday
morning when he caught a young African American teenager who had broken into
the fraternity house attempting to break into the soda machine coin box. Mr.
Roth was holding the young man by one hand and reaching for the telephone
with the other when Jeffrey asked him to wait. Jeffrey talked with the
youngster, asked him what he was doing, and stated he was going down a bad
road. Jeffrey talked Mr. Roth into letting the boy go and giving him another
chance, which he did.
After graduation, Jeffrey continued his studies at Washington University in
St. Louis, to obtain his Juris Doctorate. One day while in his third year of
law school, he noticed an employment advertisement that caught his eye. It
was advertising operational officer positions with the Central Intelligence
Agency. The ad depicted a man looking over a canal and the caption described
serving the country and seeing the world in a unique opportunity. Jeffrey
was immediately intrigued. Growing up he always wanted to see the world and
serve his country, as three of his older brothers had done in the military.
He recalls it being a great opportunity, as 3 how many times do you come
across something that may give you the opportunity of a dream you had for so
long; that was all of it wrapped into one. I was excited to see if I could
join and be a part of that organization. I felt special about the ad and the
opportunity and rushed home that day and started the process.
Jeffreys dream came true as he joined the CIA in May of 1993, training to
be a case officer. After completing training, he was assigned to the Iran
Task Force and was taught to speak Farsi. In 1997, Jeffrey was finalizing
arrangements for his first overseas post in Germany, when he was informed by
his supervisor that the job role had been assigned to another individual. It
was at that moment, his supervisor stated, we are concerned you would stick
out as a big black guy speaking Farsi. With shock and dismay, Jeffrey
replied: When did you realize I was black?
It was then that Jeffrey began to realize his dream was beginning to
unravel, as after securing a different overseas assignment he was ordered to
Germany to take the original assignment as the appointed individual had quit
the agency. Jeffrey recalls not having a choice in the matter, as he was
told you either go where we want or youre going nowhere. He agreed and
decided he was going to prove to them he was a great case officer. However,
without a proper cover or supports it made it impossible for Jeffrey to be
successful and he soon returned to the United States. Jeffrey was assigned
to the counter-proliferation division and reported to New York, where he was
again confronted with the realities of disparate treatment and unrealistic
performance expectations. Thus, Jeffrey decided to file an Equal Employment
Opportunity Complaint based on racial discrimination. Subsequently, the
agency reported no findings of racial discrimination and Jeffrey was fired
on January 31, 2002. Soon after, he was the first black officer to file a
racial discrimination lawsuit against the CIA. The case was 4 ultimately
dismissed on August 3, 2005, based on State Secrets Privilege. The judge
noted, We recognize that our decision places, on behalf of the entire
country, a burden on Sterling that he alone must bear. One New York Times
reporter, James Risen, published an article about Jeffreys discrimination
suit in 2002.
In 2003, Jeffrey went to the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence to
voice concerns he had regarding Operation Merlin, which he worked on while
at the agency. He had grave concerns about mismanagement of the program and
potential harm to our country. This was a legal and proper channel for
agency employees to voice any such concerns.
Since his termination from the agency, Jeffrey was unable to secure
employment due to the stigma of suing the CIA and was in dire financial
straits. He sold his possessions, gave his beloved cats to a neighbor and
spent nights sleeping in his car as he made his way back to St. Louis. With
no other options, Jeffrey moved in with friends and provided childcare to
their newborn daughter in exchange for room and board. He recalls it was
very humbling to go from being a case officer with the Central Intelligence
Agency to now Im a manny.
Finally, in the summer of 2004 Jeffrey caught a break and secured employment
as a Senior Fraud Investigator for WellPoint, Inc. His spirits were lifted
and he once again had an optimistic view he would be able to recover from
the devastation of his fallout with the CIA. It was on July 29, 2004, that I
had the pleasure of meeting Jeffrey for the first time, and our relationship
flourished immediately. Jeffreys life as he knew it was once again full of
promise. He thoroughly enjoyed his work and was able to utilize some of the
skills he was taught by the agency to aid in the discovery of healthcare
fraud. Jeffrey quickly became a very notable employee. Ms. Tammy Tait, a
former Pharmacy Compliance Officer, describes Jeffrey as a 5 motivated and
dedicated employee who demonstrated at all times a professional and ethical
attitude towards his work and his clients.
Jeffrey felt secure that his life was moving forward in a positive direction
and he was once again a productive member of society, that is until the FBI
came knocking on our door in the summer of 2006, with a grand jury subpoena
stating that Jeffrey was the target of an investigation regarding the
disclosure of classified information. Approximately two months later, the
FBI issued a grand jury subpoena to myself. In October, I endured seven
hours of interrogation by Special Agent Ashley Hunt and her associate at FBI
Headquarters, and the following day testified for three hours before a grand
jury. Upon returning home, I immediately received a call from my attorney
stating he was on his way to our home as the FBI was en route with a search
warrant. My attorney told me that the FBI agents had nothing on Jeffrey
because never before in any of his prior clients cases did he receive a
call from the FBI prior to a search. Minutes later, our home was surrounded
and infiltrated by at least a dozen FBI agents confiscating our personal
belongings. The sanctity of our home was violated and I had a complete
meltdown. I attempted to go to work the next day, only to be completely
emotionally overwhelmed and was sent home by my employer who stated that I
needed to leave because she thought I was suffering from Post Traumatic
Stress Disorder.
Jeffrey and I slowly recovered from the traumatic events of October 5, 2006,
and focused on our life together although there was always an uneasy feeling
of what was to come next and when. However, as time passed those feelings
lessened. Jeffrey and I were married in June of 2007, and he continued to
excel in his career receiving many accolades. In 2010, Jeffrey was awarded
Investigation of the Year Award, Honorable Mention, after identifying
Medicare fraud in Florida totaling more than 32 million dollars in false
claims. His investigation led to the 6 conviction of those responsible for
the fraudulent theft. During the hearing, the judge personally acknowledged
Jeffrey, stating that his victim impact statement illustrated the grave
implications of Medicare fraud on society. Jeffrey was also appointed as the
Ambassador of Giving for WellPoints Annual United Way Giving Campaign. It
was reported by several coworkers and friends that Jeffrey exemplified
honesty, integrity, and humility; the exact characteristics of the true
nature of the campaign. Jeffrey also personally took the time to
individually thank each employee who donated to the campaign. In the fall of
2010, Jeffrey received a call from his lawyer stating he thought the FBI
investigation was winding down as there had been no activity since our home
was searched. Jeffrey and I began to feel a sense of relief and that the
heavy burden was being lifted.
That sense of relief and security would be short lived. On January 6, 2011,
Jeffrey was asked to attend a meeting at work despite being on medical leave
after having total knee replacement surgery. Jeffrey obliged, and walking
with the assistance of a cane, reported to his office. Shortly after his
arrival, he was arrested by the FBI. WellPoint, which had just honored him
months prior, assisted in the orchestration of the false meeting and arrest.
Jeffrey was arrested on allegations of providing classified information to
the reporter, James Risen, because he was apparently disgruntled after
being fired by the CIA and having his discrimination case dismissed per the
prosecutor.
Jeffrey was transferred to a jail in Alexandria, Virginia. During the
hearing Judge Leonie Brinkema denied a request to return home, and ordered
him to stay with local friends or remain in jail. Jeffrey remained in
Virginia until the latter part of April when he was allowed to return to our
home awaiting a trial date.
Three days after Jeffreys arrest he was terminated from WellPoint. However,
in my 7 discussions with the head of human resources, they reported Jeffrey
technically resigned as he did not report for duty for three consecutive
days, as was their policy. I argued that Jeffreys legal counsel and I had
immediately called and informed WellPoint of the situation. During my
initial call, I requested that Jeffrey be placed on temporary administrative
leave without pay due to the unusual circumstances, as I was certain he
would be released and able to return to work, also noting that Jeffrey was
in good standing with his employer. Tragically, Jeffrey was never again to
be employed. His release conditions made it impossible to obtain employment
as he was ordered to inform prospective employers of being under indictment
and the charges involved. He also was subjected to random substance
screenings despite never having any history of substance abuse issues. We
also suffered the loss of friendships, as those individuals the government
deemed as potential witnesses were precluded from having any contact with
us.
Jeffrey and I would travel to Virginia, at our expense, to be present for
every pretrial hearing. We made a commitment to attend every hearing, no
matter the cost, as we were fighting for Jeffreys life. I would often work
weekends, per an agreement I made with my employer, to be able to attend the
hearings as I had continually exhausted all accrued vacation and sick time.
On the Friday prior to the October 17, 2011 trial date, it was determined
the government could not go forward with the trial, and Jeffrey and I
returned home and waited.
What exactly were we waiting for? The government was attempting to subpoena
journalist James Risen to testify that Jeffrey Sterling was his source for
the leak of classified information. A lengthy battle ensued between the
government and Mr. Risens attorneys, all the while forgetting Jeffrey.
During oral arguments on May 18, 2012, the government referred to Jeffrey as
one of the most dangerous men in our country. Jeffreys counsel, Mr.
Edward MacMahon, Jr., stated for the record, Mr. Sterling, one of the most
dangerous men in our 8 country is present today. The entire courtroom
erupted into laughter, except for Jeffrey, myself, and his attorney, who
found no humor in the statement. Our life was not a comedy, but had become
very much a tragedy.
Time marched on as we continued to endure the excruciating burden of the
pending trial, wanting desperately to return to our former life. Although
Jeffrey was determined and persisted to obtain employment, he continued to
be rejected time and time again. As time continued to fade away, so did our
dreams and monetary resources. Although I was employed as a social worker,
it was not enough to adequately pay our bills and pay for all the expenses
related to traveling back and forth to Virginia for countless hearings. In
the winter of 2014, I became unemployed for six months. We had no health
insurance, were receiving food stamps, and facing foreclosure on our home.
Our life had taken a severe turn for the worse and we had nowhere to turn.
We had to rely on the goodwill of family and friends, taking monetary loans
to keep afloat, and selling my 1998 Toyota Camry in desperate need of
repairs beyond its value. Finally, I obtained a new job and at the final
hour of losing our home, the bank was willing to grant a loan modification.
The new day had shed some light, but the darkness continued to loom as we
awaited a new trial date.
In October of 2014, we learned the trial was scheduled for January 12, 2015.
I had just begun my new job approximately one month prior and had to bare my
soul to my employer and hope they would not dismiss me due to the extreme
circumstances and time required to attend the trial. Thankfully my employer
was understanding and supportive. For the first time ever, Jeffrey attended
pretrial hearings without me, as I was saving my vacation time for the
trial. We spent the next months mentally preparing for what lay ahead and
spent countless hours engrossed in planning for the absolute worst outcome
yet maintaining constant faith that his innocence would 9 prevail.
In late December, tragedy struck as we learned that Jeffreys second-oldest
brother, Steve, was diagnosed with cancer. Jeffrey and I went to visit him
immediately, but that would be the last visit. Steve died on January 5th
while Jeffrey was in Virginia for pretrial hearings. I garnered strength and
called Jeffrey. Immediately, he knew by the tone in my voice as I did not
even say the words, and he began to sob. My heart ached as I was unable to
physically console him. All I could do was tell him how much I loved him. I
spent the evening calling Jeffreys lawyers to inform them and discuss our
options as Stevens funeral was being held on January 12, the first day of
the trial. The lawyers filed a motion requesting a delay for Jeffrey to
attend Stevens funeral. Judge Brinkema granted the motion with a delay of
only one day. Next was figuring out how Jeffrey would return home as we had
absolutely no money and were living paycheck to paycheck. Graciously, the
Simons family purchased an airplane ticket for Jeffrey to return home on
Friday evening January 9th. We spent the weekend grieving and once again
examining our limited options of returning to Virginia in time for the
trial. We decided we would have to drive straight through after Stevens
funeral as we did not have money to afford airplane tickets. Sunday
afternoon came, and friends arrived at our home to pay their respects and
visit with Jeffrey as that possibly could be the last time they would see
him. Concerned for our mental health and safety driving such a long
distance, they presented two airplane tickets for us to fly to Virginia. We
attended Steves funeral but could not accompany our family to the cemetery
as we had a three-hour drive back to St. Louis. Due to the trial, Jeffrey
and his family were cheated out of being able to grieve their loss together.
As the jury selection began, it was very evident this was clearly not a
jury of Jeffreys peers, as out of approximately 110 jurors in the jury
pool only 7 were African American and all 10 of them were struck. The
prosecution had no direct evidence to support their allegations that Jeffrey
committed the alleged acts. In fact, during cross examination of Special
Agent Ashley Hunt, she said she had no proof that Jeffrey and Mr. Risen ever
talked about the classified operation in the emails or phone calls.
Additionally, Agent Hunt testified to never obtaining the telephone and
email records of other potential leak sources. Agent Hunt stated she merely
suspected Jeffrey Sterling was the individual who leaked the information.
Defense counsel Mr. Barry Pollack also ascertained from a current CIA
manager that over 90 individuals were briefed on the classified operation.
How can the government explain that Jeffrey was their only suspect when over
90 additional individuals had opportunity and motive to divulge classified
information? Another disturbing part of the trial was when the jury foreman
reported they could not reach a decision. It was at that moment when Judge
Brinkema was once again responsible for executing the proper instructions.
Instead of stating to the jury that it was acceptable to not conclude a
unanimous decision, she told the jury to return and deliberate. After a
forty-five minute lunch break, the jury found Jeffrey guilty on all nine
counts. Completely in utter shock and despair, Jeffrey and I returned to our
home. Once again not having the financial resources, two plane tickets were
donated to us.
As we gravely awaited the sentencing hearing scheduled for April 24, 2015,
we spent every waking moment together and reviewed the decisions we
previously made prior to the trial. We spent many hours just sitting
together in silence as we could not comprehend how a jury convicted Jeffrey,
and we were terrified of the possibility of Jeffrey living the rest of his
life in prison. Shortly before the sentencing hearing, Jeffrey received a
call from his attorney stating the date of the sentencing hearing was being
moved up to our utter shock. Jeffrey was too despondent to speak so I
discussed the matter with the attorneys stating we had already 11 purchased
plane tickets and could not afford the extra $1,000 it would cost to rebook.
Not to mention, no reason was given as to the purpose of having to
reschedule the hearing. After many days of telephone calls and emails, the
new sentencing hearing was scheduled for May 11, 2015. The day came with
much trepidation as we knew the government was seeking the maximum sentence.
During the proceedings, Jeffrey addressed the court thanking them for the
delay of the trial to attend his brothers funeral and for the respect they
had shown him for the last five years. Judge Brinkema expressed the view
that the sentencing guidelines were too high, however, she said that the
offenses of John Kiriakou and Jeffrey were similar, but that Jeffrey should
get a slightly longer sentence because Mr. Kiriakou admitted his guilt in a
plea bargain, while Jeffrey admitted no wrongdoing and went to trial. Since
when is it permissible to punish someone for exercising their constitutional
right to assert their innocence?
In a similar case involving Mr. Thomas Drake, it was apparent that Judge
Richard Bennett clearly saw through the murky arguments of the government
when he questioned the prosecutor, Mr. Welch, who was also the presiding
prosecutor in Jeffreys first scheduled trial that never commenced. Judge
Bennett requested to know how many defendants waited over two and a half
years after their home was searched before an indictment is to be returned.
He reported that is an extraordinary period of delay and that the average
American citizen is entitled to an answer. Our home was searched on
October 5, 2006 and Jeffrey was indicted on December 22, 2010. That is more
than a four year delay. Judge Bennett stated, I think at some point in time
that the average citizen when their home is searched, which is a pretty, as
you and I both know, Mr. Welch, is a pretty extreme experience for those who
have experienced it, to have someone arrive at the crack of dawn and knock
on the door and come through and inventory all the items in your home. I
would think the average American after two years is entitled to know 12 what
the status of the case is. Judge Bennett further pressed Mr. Welch about
the extraordinary time frame and when he was not provided a response he
concluded that if the executive branch of government doesnt provide an
explanation, at least its up to the judicial branch to note the impropriety
of it. It was not proper. It doesnt pass the smell test. How is it Judge
Bennett was clearly cognizant of the improprieties regarding Mr. Drakes
case, yet Judge Brinkema failed to recognize the similarly improper
treatment of Jeffrey?
During the sentencing hearing, Judge Brinkema stated that Jeffrey should be
placed in a prison near our home. It is apparent yet again that Jeffrey has
been stripped of his rights, as he was placed in a Colorado prison nearly
900 miles away from his home in St. Louis. Jeffrey began serving his three
and a half year sentence on June 16, 2015.
Mr. President, I ask you to explain how this unfathomable sequence of events
has been allowed to continue for over a decade. Does the government have no
shame in destroying one mans life and wasting tens of millions of dollars
of taxpayers money to punish a man who had the audacity to do two things:
Stand up for his constitutional rights and utilize proper channels provided
to him to express concern for the citizens of our country? I am deeply
saddened by our lives events that Jeffrey and I have suffered and endured.
You publicly committed to a transparent government led by your
administration, yet it has been shrouded in mistruth and secrecy. Since you
have started your push this summer to commute prison sentences for
nonviolent offenders, will you not extend the same courtesy to an innocent
man in prison?
As your presidential election was a historical moment in this country, and
most had high hopes of actually achieving the dream that all men and women
are created equal despite the pigmentation in ones skin, it appears the
reverse has actually happened. How do you explain the obvious disparate
treatment of General Petraeus? If one strips away the race, financial
status, 13 and political clout of Jeffrey and Mr. Petraeus and solely
reviewed the alleged crimes of Jeffrey and those pled by the general, it is
glaringly obvious this was selective prosecution and sentencing. Mr.
Petraeus pled to far more egregious acts than Jeffrey was convicted of, yet
Jeffrey is rotting in a prison cell while Mr. Petraeus continues to live his
life as he so chooses. How was it that Mr. Petraeus was allowed to blatantly
lie to the FBI, which is a felony, yet this is not reflected on his criminal
record? The treatment of Mr. Petraeus solidified the reprehensible belief in
this country that the white man is presumed to be innocent and can do no
wrong, and at worst is apt to only receive a slight slap on the wrist, while
the black man is guilty until proven innocent and belongs behind bars.
The Nobel Peace Prize Laureate, Archbishop Desmond Tutu wrote in a letter to
Judge Brinkema this spring: Equality under the law as a cornerstone of
justice, is significantly at stake in the sentencing of Mr. Sterling. While
I realize that no two cases are identical, the fact remains that charges
akin to those for which Mr. Sterling was convicted have in recent years
resulted in extremely disparate penalties.
Not only has Jeffrey suffered but so have his family, friends, community and
society. And now an intelligent, strong, ethical, and productive member of
our world feels as though he ceases to exist while in prison. Dr. Chad
Holloway, a dear friend and former colleague of Jeffrey, shares: it has
been very painful for me, his other friends, and his family to observe the
ruin of Jeffreys life, with the allegations and now conviction. But, even
in time of crisis throughout this process, he has been a better friend to me
than I to him. Even with the heaviness of his situation, he always asks
about the things important to me and supports me.
Mr. President, I ask you what do you want your legacy as president to be? Is
it one in which you are remembered for prosecuting more whistleblowers than
any other previous 14 administration combined, or rather, in the words of
Pope Francis, Let us remember the Golden Rule: Do unto others as you would
have them do unto you.
Mr. President, you would be remiss not to consider what you have learned in
this letter about the true Jeffrey Sterling, as he is not the disgruntled
man who hated the CIA and wanted to settle a score as federal prosecutor
Eric G. Olshan described him. Jeffrey deserves so much better than what he
has been the recipient of.
Mr. President, this is your opportunity to show Jeffrey, our country, and
the world what it means to be a true leader by acknowledging a grave
injustice has been done and making amends. This can only be accomplished by
granting Jeffrey Alexander Sterling an immediate pardon.
Most respectfully,
Mrs. Holly Sterling
Holly Sterling is the wife of CIA whistleblower Jeffrey Sterling.
http://www.truthdig.com/ http://www.truthdig.com/
An Open Letter to President Obama From the Wife of Convicted Whistleblower
Jeffrey Sterling
http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/an_open_letter_to_president_obama_from_t
he_wife_of_20151016/
Posted on Oct 16, 2015
By Holly Sterling
Former CIA officer Jeffrey Sterling, center, accompanied by his wife, Holly,
departs federal court in Alexandria, Va., in May. (Andrew Harnik / AP)
Editors note: Earlier this year, former CIA officer and whistleblower
Jeffrey Sterling was convicted under the Espionage Act of leaking
information to New York Times reporter James Risen and sentenced to 3½ years
in prison. In the letter below, Sterlings wife appeals to President Obama
for an immediate pardon for her husband.
President Barack Obama
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Ave, NW
Washington, DC 20500
October 15, 2015
Dear Mr. President,
I am writing you on behalf of my innocent husband Mr. Jeffrey Alexander
Sterling. You know Mr. Sterling as the former disgruntled CIA Officer that
your administration indicted and prosecuted, resulting in conviction on nine
felony counts, seven of them under the antiquated Espionage Act, with a
sentence of three and a half years in prison. I would like to introduce you
to the real Jeffrey Sterling who is my best friend and husband for the past
11 years.
Jeffrey Sterling was born and raised in Cape Girardeau, Missouri. He is the
youngest of six boys, and his parents divorced at a very early age. Jeffrey
was a very inquisitive, bright, and driven child. He once took apart his
mothers radio just to see the interior working mechanisms and as a
challenge to be able to reassemble it in working order. As a young boy, he
would spend every Friday evening with his maternal grandmother visiting,
watching their beloved Cardinals baseball team, or assisting her around her
home.
Even at a young age, Jeffrey had a very strong moral code of ethics.
Jeffreys cousin, Darian Martin, fondly recollects Jeffrey as always being
like a big brother to me. I always looked up to Jeff because he was
extremely talented. He was an artist, musician, a writer, and was also an
outstanding athlete to name a few of his qualities. Jeff also spent time
with me and 2 our other cousins and instilled discipline in our lives. He is
truly a role model and one of the most successful members of our family.
Jeff has always been an honest person and has always made excellent
decisions. Jeff gave me hope that I could grow up and be someone, and that
is exactly what I have done by walking in his footsteps.
Jeffrey enjoyed and excelled at academics and knew from an early age he
would attend college; as it turned out he was the only one of his siblings
to do so. After graduating from high school, Jeffrey attended Millikin
University and pursued a political science degree. During his schooling, he
became a member of the Tau Kappa Epsilon Fraternity where he met and
befriended current Commander William Roth of the United States Navy Reserve
Component. Mr. Roth describes Jeffrey as selfless, he regularly put the
needs and wants of others ahead of his own. Mr. Roth recalled a Sunday
morning when he caught a young African American teenager who had broken into
the fraternity house attempting to break into the soda machine coin box. Mr.
Roth was holding the young man by one hand and reaching for the telephone
with the other when Jeffrey asked him to wait. Jeffrey talked with the
youngster, asked him what he was doing, and stated he was going down a bad
road. Jeffrey talked Mr. Roth into letting the boy go and giving him another
chance, which he did.
After graduation, Jeffrey continued his studies at Washington University in
St. Louis, to obtain his Juris Doctorate. One day while in his third year of
law school, he noticed an employment advertisement that caught his eye. It
was advertising operational officer positions with the Central Intelligence
Agency. The ad depicted a man looking over a canal and the caption described
serving the country and seeing the world in a unique opportunity. Jeffrey
was immediately intrigued. Growing up he always wanted to see the world and
serve his country, as three of his older brothers had done in the military.
He recalls it being a great opportunity, as 3 how many times do you come
across something that may give you the opportunity of a dream you had for so
long; that was all of it wrapped into one. I was excited to see if I could
join and be a part of that organization. I felt special about the ad and the
opportunity and rushed home that day and started the process.
Jeffreys dream came true as he joined the CIA in May of 1993, training to
be a case officer. After completing training, he was assigned to the Iran
Task Force and was taught to speak Farsi. In 1997, Jeffrey was finalizing
arrangements for his first overseas post in Germany, when he was informed by
his supervisor that the job role had been assigned to another individual. It
was at that moment, his supervisor stated, we are concerned you would stick
out as a big black guy speaking Farsi. With shock and dismay, Jeffrey
replied: When did you realize I was black?
It was then that Jeffrey began to realize his dream was beginning to
unravel, as after securing a different overseas assignment he was ordered to
Germany to take the original assignment as the appointed individual had quit
the agency. Jeffrey recalls not having a choice in the matter, as he was
told you either go where we want or youre going nowhere. He agreed and
decided he was going to prove to them he was a great case officer. However,
without a proper cover or supports it made it impossible for Jeffrey to be
successful and he soon returned to the United States. Jeffrey was assigned
to the counter-proliferation division and reported to New York, where he was
again confronted with the realities of disparate treatment and unrealistic
performance expectations. Thus, Jeffrey decided to file an Equal Employment
Opportunity Complaint based on racial discrimination. Subsequently, the
agency reported no findings of racial discrimination and Jeffrey was fired
on January 31, 2002. Soon after, he was the first black officer to file a
racial discrimination lawsuit against the CIA. The case was 4 ultimately
dismissed on August 3, 2005, based on State Secrets Privilege. The judge
noted, We recognize that our decision places, on behalf of the entire
country, a burden on Sterling that he alone must bear. One New York Times
reporter, James Risen, published an article about Jeffreys discrimination
suit in 2002.
In 2003, Jeffrey went to the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence to
voice concerns he had regarding Operation Merlin, which he worked on while
at the agency. He had grave concerns about mismanagement of the program and
potential harm to our country. This was a legal and proper channel for
agency employees to voice any such concerns.
Since his termination from the agency, Jeffrey was unable to secure
employment due to the stigma of suing the CIA and was in dire financial
straits. He sold his possessions, gave his beloved cats to a neighbor and
spent nights sleeping in his car as he made his way back to St. Louis. With
no other options, Jeffrey moved in with friends and provided childcare to
their newborn daughter in exchange for room and board. He recalls it was
very humbling to go from being a case officer with the Central Intelligence
Agency to now Im a manny.
Finally, in the summer of 2004 Jeffrey caught a break and secured employment
as a Senior Fraud Investigator for WellPoint, Inc. His spirits were lifted
and he once again had an optimistic view he would be able to recover from
the devastation of his fallout with the CIA. It was on July 29, 2004, that I
had the pleasure of meeting Jeffrey for the first time, and our relationship
flourished immediately. Jeffreys life as he knew it was once again full of
promise. He thoroughly enjoyed his work and was able to utilize some of the
skills he was taught by the agency to aid in the discovery of healthcare
fraud. Jeffrey quickly became a very notable employee. Ms. Tammy Tait, a
former Pharmacy Compliance Officer, describes Jeffrey as a 5 motivated and
dedicated employee who demonstrated at all times a professional and ethical
attitude towards his work and his clients.
Jeffrey felt secure that his life was moving forward in a positive direction
and he was once again a productive member of society, that is until the FBI
came knocking on our door in the summer of 2006, with a grand jury subpoena
stating that Jeffrey was the target of an investigation regarding the
disclosure of classified information. Approximately two months later, the
FBI issued a grand jury subpoena to myself. In October, I endured seven
hours of interrogation by Special Agent Ashley Hunt and her associate at FBI
Headquarters, and the following day testified for three hours before a grand
jury. Upon returning home, I immediately received a call from my attorney
stating he was on his way to our home as the FBI was en route with a search
warrant. My attorney told me that the FBI agents had nothing on Jeffrey
because never before in any of his prior clients cases did he receive a
call from the FBI prior to a search. Minutes later, our home was surrounded
and infiltrated by at least a dozen FBI agents confiscating our personal
belongings. The sanctity of our home was violated and I had a complete
meltdown. I attempted to go to work the next day, only to be completely
emotionally overwhelmed and was sent home by my employer who stated that I
needed to leave because she thought I was suffering from Post Traumatic
Stress Disorder.
Jeffrey and I slowly recovered from the traumatic events of October 5, 2006,
and focused on our life together although there was always an uneasy feeling
of what was to come next and when. However, as time passed those feelings
lessened. Jeffrey and I were married in June of 2007, and he continued to
excel in his career receiving many accolades. In 2010, Jeffrey was awarded
Investigation of the Year Award, Honorable Mention, after identifying
Medicare fraud in Florida totaling more than 32 million dollars in false
claims. His investigation led to the 6 conviction of those responsible for
the fraudulent theft. During the hearing, the judge personally acknowledged
Jeffrey, stating that his victim impact statement illustrated the grave
implications of Medicare fraud on society. Jeffrey was also appointed as the
Ambassador of Giving for WellPoints Annual United Way Giving Campaign. It
was reported by several coworkers and friends that Jeffrey exemplified
honesty, integrity, and humility; the exact characteristics of the true
nature of the campaign. Jeffrey also personally took the time to
individually thank each employee who donated to the campaign. In the fall of
2010, Jeffrey received a call from his lawyer stating he thought the FBI
investigation was winding down as there had been no activity since our home
was searched. Jeffrey and I began to feel a sense of relief and that the
heavy burden was being lifted.
That sense of relief and security would be short lived. On January 6, 2011,
Jeffrey was asked to attend a meeting at work despite being on medical leave
after having total knee replacement surgery. Jeffrey obliged, and walking
with the assistance of a cane, reported to his office. Shortly after his
arrival, he was arrested by the FBI. WellPoint, which had just honored him
months prior, assisted in the orchestration of the false meeting and arrest.
Jeffrey was arrested on allegations of providing classified information to
the reporter, James Risen, because he was apparently disgruntled after
being fired by the CIA and having his discrimination case dismissed per the
prosecutor.
Jeffrey was transferred to a jail in Alexandria, Virginia. During the
hearing Judge Leonie Brinkema denied a request to return home, and ordered
him to stay with local friends or remain in jail. Jeffrey remained in
Virginia until the latter part of April when he was allowed to return to our
home awaiting a trial date.
Three days after Jeffreys arrest he was terminated from WellPoint. However,
in my 7 discussions with the head of human resources, they reported Jeffrey
technically resigned as he did not report for duty for three consecutive
days, as was their policy. I argued that Jeffreys legal counsel and I had
immediately called and informed WellPoint of the situation. During my
initial call, I requested that Jeffrey be placed on temporary administrative
leave without pay due to the unusual circumstances, as I was certain he
would be released and able to return to work, also noting that Jeffrey was
in good standing with his employer. Tragically, Jeffrey was never again to
be employed. His release conditions made it impossible to obtain employment
as he was ordered to inform prospective employers of being under indictment
and the charges involved. He also was subjected to random substance
screenings despite never having any history of substance abuse issues. We
also suffered the loss of friendships, as those individuals the government
deemed as potential witnesses were precluded from having any contact with
us.
Jeffrey and I would travel to Virginia, at our expense, to be present for
every pretrial hearing. We made a commitment to attend every hearing, no
matter the cost, as we were fighting for Jeffreys life. I would often work
weekends, per an agreement I made with my employer, to be able to attend the
hearings as I had continually exhausted all accrued vacation and sick time.
On the Friday prior to the October 17, 2011 trial date, it was determined
the government could not go forward with the trial, and Jeffrey and I
returned home and waited.
What exactly were we waiting for? The government was attempting to subpoena
journalist James Risen to testify that Jeffrey Sterling was his source for
the leak of classified information. A lengthy battle ensued between the
government and Mr. Risens attorneys, all the while forgetting Jeffrey.
During oral arguments on May 18, 2012, the government referred to Jeffrey as
one of the most dangerous men in our country. Jeffreys counsel, Mr.
Edward MacMahon, Jr., stated for the record, Mr. Sterling, one of the most
dangerous men in our 8 country is present today. The entire courtroom
erupted into laughter, except for Jeffrey, myself, and his attorney, who
found no humor in the statement. Our life was not a comedy, but had become
very much a tragedy.
Time marched on as we continued to endure the excruciating burden of the
pending trial, wanting desperately to return to our former life. Although
Jeffrey was determined and persisted to obtain employment, he continued to
be rejected time and time again. As time continued to fade away, so did our
dreams and monetary resources. Although I was employed as a social worker,
it was not enough to adequately pay our bills and pay for all the expenses
related to traveling back and forth to Virginia for countless hearings. In
the winter of 2014, I became unemployed for six months. We had no health
insurance, were receiving food stamps, and facing foreclosure on our home.
Our life had taken a severe turn for the worse and we had nowhere to turn.
We had to rely on the goodwill of family and friends, taking monetary loans
to keep afloat, and selling my 1998 Toyota Camry in desperate need of
repairs beyond its value. Finally, I obtained a new job and at the final
hour of losing our home, the bank was willing to grant a loan modification.
The new day had shed some light, but the darkness continued to loom as we
awaited a new trial date.
In October of 2014, we learned the trial was scheduled for January 12, 2015.
I had just begun my new job approximately one month prior and had to bare my
soul to my employer and hope they would not dismiss me due to the extreme
circumstances and time required to attend the trial. Thankfully my employer
was understanding and supportive. For the first time ever, Jeffrey attended
pretrial hearings without me, as I was saving my vacation time for the
trial. We spent the next months mentally preparing for what lay ahead and
spent countless hours engrossed in planning for the absolute worst outcome
yet maintaining constant faith that his innocence would 9 prevail.
In late December, tragedy struck as we learned that Jeffreys second-oldest
brother, Steve, was diagnosed with cancer. Jeffrey and I went to visit him
immediately, but that would be the last visit. Steve died on January 5th
while Jeffrey was in Virginia for pretrial hearings. I garnered strength and
called Jeffrey. Immediately, he knew by the tone in my voice as I did not
even say the words, and he began to sob. My heart ached as I was unable to
physically console him. All I could do was tell him how much I loved him. I
spent the evening calling Jeffreys lawyers to inform them and discuss our
options as Stevens funeral was being held on January 12, the first day of
the trial. The lawyers filed a motion requesting a delay for Jeffrey to
attend Stevens funeral. Judge Brinkema granted the motion with a delay of
only one day. Next was figuring out how Jeffrey would return home as we had
absolutely no money and were living paycheck to paycheck. Graciously, the
Simons family purchased an airplane ticket for Jeffrey to return home on
Friday evening January 9th. We spent the weekend grieving and once again
examining our limited options of returning to Virginia in time for the
trial. We decided we would have to drive straight through after Stevens
funeral as we did not have money to afford airplane tickets. Sunday
afternoon came, and friends arrived at our home to pay their respects and
visit with Jeffrey as that possibly could be the last time they would see
him. Concerned for our mental health and safety driving such a long
distance, they presented two airplane tickets for us to fly to Virginia. We
attended Steves funeral but could not accompany our family to the cemetery
as we had a three-hour drive back to St. Louis. Due to the trial, Jeffrey
and his family were cheated out of being able to grieve their loss together.
As the jury selection began, it was very evident this was clearly not a
jury of Jeffreys peers, as out of approximately 110 jurors in the jury
pool only 7 were African American and all 10 of them were struck. The
prosecution had no direct evidence to support their allegations that Jeffrey
committed the alleged acts. In fact, during cross examination of Special
Agent Ashley Hunt, she said she had no proof that Jeffrey and Mr. Risen ever
talked about the classified operation in the emails or phone calls.
Additionally, Agent Hunt testified to never obtaining the telephone and
email records of other potential leak sources. Agent Hunt stated she merely
suspected Jeffrey Sterling was the individual who leaked the information.
Defense counsel Mr. Barry Pollack also ascertained from a current CIA
manager that over 90 individuals were briefed on the classified operation.
How can the government explain that Jeffrey was their only suspect when over
90 additional individuals had opportunity and motive to divulge classified
information? Another disturbing part of the trial was when the jury foreman
reported they could not reach a decision. It was at that moment when Judge
Brinkema was once again responsible for executing the proper instructions.
Instead of stating to the jury that it was acceptable to not conclude a
unanimous decision, she told the jury to return and deliberate. After a
forty-five minute lunch break, the jury found Jeffrey guilty on all nine
counts. Completely in utter shock and despair, Jeffrey and I returned to our
home. Once again not having the financial resources, two plane tickets were
donated to us.
As we gravely awaited the sentencing hearing scheduled for April 24, 2015,
we spent every waking moment together and reviewed the decisions we
previously made prior to the trial. We spent many hours just sitting
together in silence as we could not comprehend how a jury convicted Jeffrey,
and we were terrified of the possibility of Jeffrey living the rest of his
life in prison. Shortly before the sentencing hearing, Jeffrey received a
call from his attorney stating the date of the sentencing hearing was being
moved up to our utter shock. Jeffrey was too despondent to speak so I
discussed the matter with the attorneys stating we had already 11 purchased
plane tickets and could not afford the extra $1,000 it would cost to rebook.
Not to mention, no reason was given as to the purpose of having to
reschedule the hearing. After many days of telephone calls and emails, the
new sentencing hearing was scheduled for May 11, 2015. The day came with
much trepidation as we knew the government was seeking the maximum sentence.
During the proceedings, Jeffrey addressed the court thanking them for the
delay of the trial to attend his brothers funeral and for the respect they
had shown him for the last five years. Judge Brinkema expressed the view
that the sentencing guidelines were too high, however, she said that the
offenses of John Kiriakou and Jeffrey were similar, but that Jeffrey should
get a slightly longer sentence because Mr. Kiriakou admitted his guilt in a
plea bargain, while Jeffrey admitted no wrongdoing and went to trial. Since
when is it permissible to punish someone for exercising their constitutional
right to assert their innocence?
In a similar case involving Mr. Thomas Drake, it was apparent that Judge
Richard Bennett clearly saw through the murky arguments of the government
when he questioned the prosecutor, Mr. Welch, who was also the presiding
prosecutor in Jeffreys first scheduled trial that never commenced. Judge
Bennett requested to know how many defendants waited over two and a half
years after their home was searched before an indictment is to be returned.
He reported that is an extraordinary period of delay and that the average
American citizen is entitled to an answer. Our home was searched on
October 5, 2006 and Jeffrey was indicted on December 22, 2010. That is more
than a four year delay. Judge Bennett stated, I think at some point in time
that the average citizen when their home is searched, which is a pretty, as
you and I both know, Mr. Welch, is a pretty extreme experience for those who
have experienced it, to have someone arrive at the crack of dawn and knock
on the door and come through and inventory all the items in your home. I
would think the average American after two years is entitled to know 12 what
the status of the case is. Judge Bennett further pressed Mr. Welch about
the extraordinary time frame and when he was not provided a response he
concluded that if the executive branch of government doesnt provide an
explanation, at least its up to the judicial branch to note the impropriety
of it. It was not proper. It doesnt pass the smell test. How is it Judge
Bennett was clearly cognizant of the improprieties regarding Mr. Drakes
case, yet Judge Brinkema failed to recognize the similarly improper
treatment of Jeffrey?
During the sentencing hearing, Judge Brinkema stated that Jeffrey should be
placed in a prison near our home. It is apparent yet again that Jeffrey has
been stripped of his rights, as he was placed in a Colorado prison nearly
900 miles away from his home in St. Louis. Jeffrey began serving his three
and a half year sentence on June 16, 2015.
Mr. President, I ask you to explain how this unfathomable sequence of events
has been allowed to continue for over a decade. Does the government have no
shame in destroying one mans life and wasting tens of millions of dollars
of taxpayers money to punish a man who had the audacity to do two things:
Stand up for his constitutional rights and utilize proper channels provided
to him to express concern for the citizens of our country? I am deeply
saddened by our lives events that Jeffrey and I have suffered and endured.
You publicly committed to a transparent government led by your
administration, yet it has been shrouded in mistruth and secrecy. Since you
have started your push this summer to commute prison sentences for
nonviolent offenders, will you not extend the same courtesy to an innocent
man in prison?
As your presidential election was a historical moment in this country, and
most had high hopes of actually achieving the dream that all men and women
are created equal despite the pigmentation in ones skin, it appears the
reverse has actually happened. How do you explain the obvious disparate
treatment of General Petraeus? If one strips away the race, financial
status, 13 and political clout of Jeffrey and Mr. Petraeus and solely
reviewed the alleged crimes of Jeffrey and those pled by the general, it is
glaringly obvious this was selective prosecution and sentencing. Mr.
Petraeus pled to far more egregious acts than Jeffrey was convicted of, yet
Jeffrey is rotting in a prison cell while Mr. Petraeus continues to live his
life as he so chooses. How was it that Mr. Petraeus was allowed to blatantly
lie to the FBI, which is a felony, yet this is not reflected on his criminal
record? The treatment of Mr. Petraeus solidified the reprehensible belief in
this country that the white man is presumed to be innocent and can do no
wrong, and at worst is apt to only receive a slight slap on the wrist, while
the black man is guilty until proven innocent and belongs behind bars.
The Nobel Peace Prize Laureate, Archbishop Desmond Tutu wrote in a letter to
Judge Brinkema this spring: Equality under the law as a cornerstone of
justice, is significantly at stake in the sentencing of Mr. Sterling. While
I realize that no two cases are identical, the fact remains that charges
akin to those for which Mr. Sterling was convicted have in recent years
resulted in extremely disparate penalties.
Not only has Jeffrey suffered but so have his family, friends, community and
society. And now an intelligent, strong, ethical, and productive member of
our world feels as though he ceases to exist while in prison. Dr. Chad
Holloway, a dear friend and former colleague of Jeffrey, shares: it has
been very painful for me, his other friends, and his family to observe the
ruin of Jeffreys life, with the allegations and now conviction. But, even
in time of crisis throughout this process, he has been a better friend to me
than I to him. Even with the heaviness of his situation, he always asks
about the things important to me and supports me.
Mr. President, I ask you what do you want your legacy as president to be? Is
it one in which you are remembered for prosecuting more whistleblowers than
any other previous 14 administration combined, or rather, in the words of
Pope Francis, Let us remember the Golden Rule: Do unto others as you would
have them do unto you.
Mr. President, you would be remiss not to consider what you have learned in
this letter about the true Jeffrey Sterling, as he is not the disgruntled
man who hated the CIA and wanted to settle a score as federal prosecutor
Eric G. Olshan described him. Jeffrey deserves so much better than what he
has been the recipient of.
Mr. President, this is your opportunity to show Jeffrey, our country, and
the world what it means to be a true leader by acknowledging a grave
injustice has been done and making amends. This can only be accomplished by
granting Jeffrey Alexander Sterling an immediate pardon.
Most respectfully,
Mrs. Holly Sterling
Holly Sterling is the wife of CIA whistleblower Jeffrey Sterling.
http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/bernie_blew_it_he_sold_out_instead_of_co
nfronting_clinton_20151016/
http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/bernie_blew_it_he_sold_out_instead_of_co
nfronting_clinton_20151016/
http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/bernie_blew_it_he_sold_out_instead_of_co
nfronting_clinton_20151016/
http://www.truthdig.com/avbooth/item/video_this_artist_is_erasing_the_us-mex
ico_border_fence_with_blue_paint_2/
http://www.truthdig.com/avbooth/item/video_this_artist_is_erasing_the_us-mex
ico_border_fence_with_blue_paint_2/
http://www.truthdig.com/avbooth/item/video_this_artist_is_erasing_the_us-mex
ico_border_fence_with_blue_paint_2/
http://www.truthdig.com/avbooth/item/video_drone_war_exposed_jeremy_scahill_
on_us_kill_programs_secrets_201510/
http://www.truthdig.com/avbooth/item/video_drone_war_exposed_jeremy_scahill_
on_us_kill_programs_secrets_201510/
http://www.truthdig.com/avbooth/item/video_drone_war_exposed_jeremy_scahill_
on_us_kill_programs_secrets_201510/
http://www.truthdig.com/avbooth/item/bernie_sanders_dances_and_talks_inequal
ity_with_ellen_degeneres_20151016/
http://www.truthdig.com/avbooth/item/bernie_sanders_dances_and_talks_inequal
ity_with_ellen_degeneres_20151016/
http://www.truthdig.com/avbooth/item/bernie_sanders_dances_and_talks_inequal
ity_with_ellen_degeneres_20151016/ http://www.truthdig.com/
http://www.truthdig.com/
http://www.truthdig.com/about/http://www.truthdig.com/contact/http://www.tru
thdig.com/about/advertising/http://www.truthdig.com/user_agreement/http://ww
w.truthdig.com/privacy_policy/http://www.truthdig.com/about/comment_policy/
© 2015 Truthdig, LLC. All rights reserved.
http://www.hopstudios.com/
http://support.truthdig.com/signup_page/subscribe
http://support.truthdig.com/signup_page/subscribe
http://www.facebook.com/truthdighttp://twitter.com/intent/follow?source=foll
owbutton&variant=1.0&screen_name=truthdighttps://plus.google.com/+truthdight
tp://www.linkedin.com/company/truthdighttp://truthdig.tumblr.com/http://www.
truthdig.com/connect