https://socialistaction.org/2019/01/08/angela-nagles-shoddy-remedies-for-the-migrant-crisis/
Angela Nagle’s shoddy remedies for the ‘migrant crisis.’
/ 2 days ago
jan. 2019 border tents (marty)
As caravan migrants wait at the U.S. border in December, Mexican police
roust them from a make-shift tent city near Benito Juárez Stadium in
Tijuana. (Photo: Marty Goodman / Socialist Action)
By IVAN DOLPHY
In late December, Angela Nagle, author of “Kill All Normies” and a
supposedly left thinker, penned a piece for the conservative journal
American Affairs entitled “The Left Case Against Open Borders.” In her
article she scores the “left” for employing the slogan “no human is
illegal,” charging that it is an implicit demand for “no borders or no
sovereign states at all.” Instead, she advocates the restriction of
migration and the implementation of E-Verify-type registration measures,
which in her eyes are a humane way to curb immigration.
The central logic of her argument is that big business uses cheap labor
to undercut domestic labor and thus undermine the already embattled
state of organized labor.
Despite its “leftist” tinge, Nagle’s article mirrors the recent summit
of Hillary Clinton, Matteo Renzi, and Tony Blair, neoliberalism’s
finest, who advocate the curbing of immigration in Europe in order to
assuage the racist demands of swelling white nationalist movements in
the EU. What they are really saying is: “In order to stop the far right,
we must implement their policies,” or if you prefer: “if you can’t beat
’em, join ’em.”
As a foundation for her diatribe, Nagle insists that the notion of open
borders is a somewhat recent notion in left politics and that the
embrace of such an idea makes “useful idiots” of us all on behalf of big
business, which stands to capitalize on increased competition in the
labor market.
Let’s set aside the fact that granting full legal status to all
immigrants would immediately change the condition that makes them so
exploitable to capitalists in the first place. The truth is that there
has always been a strong current of internationalism and workers’
solidarity in left politics. There is no asterisk in the slogan “Workers
of the World, Unite!”
Nagle is accurate, of course, in pointing out that “trade unions have
often opposed mass migration.” She goes on to mention that racism and
xenophobia have been an issue with trade unions. In fact, it was a
central point of contention in U.S. labor history between the more
reactionary AFL and the more radical IWW, the latter of which recognized
that the bosses profited from imported cheap labor but that the
solution, rather than a craft-centric narrow-mindedness, was to
“recognize that all workers belong to the international nation of wealth
producers” and end competition by “owning the means of production.”
In introducing her remedies for what she calls “the migrant crisis,”
Nagle uses a quotation from Karl Marx about how the English capitalists
used cheap Irish labor as a wedge to divide workers. And she notes
Marx’s observation that English workers would help themselves by
embracing the struggle of the Irish for their emancipation from British
colonial domination.
Similarly, Nagle calls for the amelioration of the economic conditions
that today’s migrants face in their own countries, as a way to keep them
home. But she ignores the fact that Marx said nowhere that part of the
solution was to restrict the immigration of Irish workers—the sort of
immigration policy that she advocates for the United States today.
Nagle goes on to implore the left to embrace E-verify, a policy that
would place the onus on employers to verify the immigration status of
all of their workers, and would punish businesses for noncompliance.
Proponents of this policy claim that it’s a humane way to encourage the
self-deportation of undocumented people. Basically, their reasoning is
that by creating more barriers between undocumented immigrants and jobs
or services it would softly encourage them to leave or not migrate in
the first place.
This is a polite way of saying that the best way to make “undesirable”
people leave is to choke them of resources, so that their lives become
unlivable. How humane!
Nowhere in the article does Nagle outline what this would look like for
the 11 million undocumented people already living and working in the
United States. She only talks about her “solution” in the abstract, and
that’s because it looks horrifying in practice.
In reality, it would force many immigrant laborers into the black
market, where they are even more desperate and exploitable. It would be
to the delight of pimps, drug dealers, and human traffickers. It would
uproot entire communities, and it would give ICE even more technocratic
tools to carry out their systematic atrocities. Call this anything but
humane.
A more rational conclusion should recognize that immigrants must be
embraced in labor organizing efforts within the United States, as they
are made even more vulnerable by their marginal status and are therefore
more easily radicalized. Immigrants fleeing hardship have fewer
illusions about the uncaring nature of the capitalist state precisely
because of their lived experience.
This can be witnessed first hand with the leading role that immigrant
workers are playing in organizing efforts at hotels, fast-food
restaurants, and meat-packing plants.
Free movement around the planet should be, as Frederick Douglass put it,
an “indestructible” human right. Beneath her poorly constructed
arguments lies an implicit prejudice: Her shoddy veneer of compassion
belies the same foul chauvinism that plagued the Social Democratic
tradition of the Second International, which she is now trying to
reproduce in the awakening U.S. left.
Given that Nagle is now officially on the payroll of a rag that changed
its name from The Journal of American Greatness, it poses the question
of who the useful idiot to big business might be.
Share this:
Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)
January 8, 2019 in Immigration.
Related posts
Tensions rise as migrant caravans arrive at the U.S.-Mexico border
Solidarity with the migrant caravan!
The caravan that defies borders
Post navigation
← Trump’s Syria exit provokes Washington panic
Get Involved!
Donate to help support our work
Get email updates
Join Socialist Action
Newspaper Archives
Newspaper Archives Select Month January 2019 (4) December 2018 (12)
November 2018 (15) October 2018 (10) September 2018 (8) August 2018
(12) July 2018 (13) June 2018 (11) May 2018 (19) April 2018 (15)
March 2018 (17) February 2018 (14) January 2018 (13) December 2017
(13) November 2017 (13) October 2017 (16) September 2017 (15) August
2017 (16) July 2017 (17) June 2017 (16) May 2017 (17) April 2017
(14) March 2017 (13) February 2017 (19) January 2017 (13) December
2016 (12) November 2016 (19) October 2016 (12) September 2016 (10)
August 2016 (10) July 2016 (14) June 2016 (14) May 2016 (9) April
2016 (12) March 2016 (14) February 2016 (8) January 2016 (11)
December 2015 (11) November 2015 (9) October 2015 (8) September 2015
(10) August 2015 (7) July 2015 (13) June 2015 (9) May 2015 (10)
April 2015 (12) March 2015 (9) February 2015 (11) January 2015 (10)
December 2014 (12) November 2014 (11) October 2014 (9) September
2014 (6) August 2014 (10) July 2014 (11) June 2014 (10) May 2014
(11) April 2014 (10) March 2014 (9) February 2014 (11) January 2014
(11) December 2013 (10) November 2013 (11) October 2013 (17)
September 2013 (13) August 2013 (10) July 2013 (11) June 2013 (15)
May 2013 (14) April 2013 (14) March 2013 (12) February 2013 (10)
January 2013 (17) December 2012 (7) November 2012 (8) October 2012
(19) September 2012 (2) August 2012 (27) July 2012 (18) June 2012
(3) May 2012 (19) April 2012 (14) March 2012 (17) February 2012 (19)
January 2012 (17) December 2011 (3) November 2011 (33) October 2011
(14) September 2011 (13) August 2011 (34) July 2011 (24) June 2011
(19) May 2011 (19) April 2011 (15) March 2011 (15) February 2011
(15) January 2011 (15) December 2010 (17) November 2010 (1) October
2010 (6) September 2010 (3) August 2010 (8) July 2010 (7) June 2010
(2) May 2010 (10) April 2010 (3) March 2010 (8) February 2010 (3)
January 2010 (9) December 2009 (6) November 2009 (5) October 2009
(16) September 2009 (3) August 2009 (2) July 2009 (5) June 2009 (2)
May 2009 (7) April 2009 (6) March 2009 (16) February 2009 (9)
January 2009 (10) December 2008 (11) November 2008 (8) October 2008
(16) September 2008 (14) August 2008 (18) July 2008 (12) June 2008
(3) May 2008 (2) April 2008 (3) March 2008 (14) February 2008 (11)
January 2008 (11) December 2007 (8) November 2007 (1) July 2007 (1)
June 2007 (1) April 2007 (1) March 2007 (1) February 2007 (3)
December 2006 (11) November 2006 (11) October 2006 (13) September
2006 (15) August 2006 (11) July 2006 (18) June 2006 (7) May 2006
(14) April 2006 (6) March 2006 (14) February 2006 (5) January 2006
(2) December 2005 (9) November 2005 (8) October 2005 (13) September
2005 (12) August 2005 (9) July 2005 (16) June 2005 (16) May 2005
(16) April 2005 (12) March 2005 (14) February 2005 (19) January 2005
(15) December 2004 (14) November 2002 (17) October 2002 (19) September
2002 (22) August 2002 (21) July 2002 (15) May 2002 (21) April 2002
(21) February 2002 (15) January 2002 (15) December 2001 (17) October
2001 (24) September 2001 (18) July 2001 (19) June 2001 (18) October
2000 (17) September 2000 (21) August 2000 (19) July 2000 (16) June
2000 (26) May 2000 (21) April 2000 (22) March 2000 (28) February
2000 (18) January 2000 (20) December 1999 (20) November 1999 (26)
October 1999 (25) September 1999 (18) August 1999 (40) July 1999
(38) June 1999 (24) May 1999 (27) April 1999 (25) March 1999 (26)
February 1999 (29) January 1999 (24) July 1998 (12)
Search
View socialistactionusa’s profile on Facebook
View SocialistActUS’s profile on Twitter
View SocialistActionCT’s profile on YouTube
Subscribe to Our Newspaper
Upcoming Events
No upcoming events
Category Cloud
Actions & Protest Africa Anti-War Arts & Culture Black Liberation Canada
Caribbean Civil Liberties Cuba East Asia Economy Education & Schools
Elections Environment Europe Immigration Indigenous Rights International
Labor Latin America Latino Civil Liberties Marxist Theory & History
Middle East Palestine Police & FBI Prisons South Asia Trump / U.S.
Government Uncategorized Women's Liberation
View Calendar
Blog at WordPress.com.
Follow
--
________________________________________________
Jules Verne
“ Reality provides us with facts so romantic that imagination itself could add
nothing to them. ”
― Jules Verne