Dear Joe Scarborough: Invite Me To Debate Your Network's Putrid Russiagate
Coverage
"Morning Joe" says those who reported on Russia errors are a "joke" and may
be "on Russia's payroll." MSNBC should break its four-year freeze-out and
invite a skeptic to respond
Matt Taibbi
Mar 29
Joe Scarborough just had this to say on Morning Joe:
The Elegant Diplomat @ElegantDiplomat
@mtaibbi you may like this one Scarborough Laments Reporters Who
Investigate How Media 'Screwed Up' on Russia: 'Useful Idiots'MSNBC host Joe
Scarborough lamented reporters who investigate where reporting about Russian
involvement in the 2016 election went wrong, calling them "useful
idiots."mediaite.com
March 29th 2021
Joe begins his rant by insinuating that those who've spent time documenting
errors on the Russiagate story are maybe on "Russia's payroll," which is
nothing new for this network, of course, or frankly for the press in general
during this time.
Implying that anyone who didn't buy into the moral panic on Russia was a
traitor was a fairly constant theme in media and politics in the last four
years, with NBC's smear of Tulsi Gabbard as a "favorite" of "Russia's
propaganda machine" being one of the ethical low points of the era. Why
should Joe Scarborough be above the same tactics?
The exact quote:
I'm amused by so-called reporters who - I don't know if they're useful
idiots for Russia, or if they're on Russia's payroll . but there are some
gifted writers who spend all night and day, trying to dig through, looking
for instances where the press screwed up on Russia stories.
He went on to say that yes, there were instances of mistakes, and some bad
mistakes, but "more often than not," the press got it right. Perhaps this
could be a new slogan for the network:
MSNBC. We get it right. More often than not.
The full quote:
If you look at the totality of it, the totality of everything - I mean,
yeah, the media screwed up at some points, and sometimes they screwed up
badly. But more often than not, they got it right.
Obviously, I won't presume that he's talking about me when he mentions "some
gifted writers" who may or may not be foreign spies, criticizing networks
like his. He could be referring to Aaron Mate, or Glenn Greenwald, perhaps
even Erik Wemple of the Washington Post, whose critique of Scarborough's
colleague Rachel Maddow's Russia coverage was scathing enough.
It doesn't matter, as the universe of people actually doing such work isn't
large. I do have a recent piece out, "Master List Of Official Russia Claims
That Proved To Be Bogus," that sounds like the kind of thing annoying him,
so I'm happy to respond on behalf of the group.
The humorous thing about this is that the group of writers who have spoken
out on this topic is small enough that we all communicate with each other.
We've been able to calculate that I was actually the last of the Russiagate
skeptics invited on MSNBC, on January 13, 2017 - before Trump's inauguration
- when I joined Chris Hayes and Malcolm Nance to discuss what at the time
was a red-hot story.
The irony is that one of the major criticisms of the media's performance on
this issue is that it has not allowed any critics of the story to appear
really anywhere in the mainstream press, and particularly not on television,
for nearly four years. I doubt they will break that on-air pattern even now.
Still, it's worth asking Scarborough: if you're so certain this issue is a
"joke," surely you won't mind discussing it?
If you'd rather not have me on, I'm sure someone on the more critical side
would be happy to walk you through exactly how far short of "right, more
often than not" your network has been in the last five years or so. Most of
the major outlets were terrible on this story, but MSNBC's particular brand
of suckage was visible from space during the key years of Russiagate. Which
I'm happy to lay out for you. Come on - no matter how it turns out, it'll be
great TV!
Thanks for subscribing to TK News by Matt Taibbi. This post is public, so
feel free to share it.
Share
Give a gift subscription
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
Youtube
C 2021 Matt Taibbi Unsubscribe
548 Market Street PMB 72296, San Francisco, CA 94104