https://www.peoplesworld.org/article/participants-in-the-radical-student-upsurge-speak-out-in-this-volume/
Participants in the radical student upsurge speak out in this volume
August 1, 2019|?????? 10:07 AM CDT| | By Tony Pecinovsky
Share
???
Email
Participants in the radical student upsurge speak out in this volume
Participant reflections of the tumultuous 1960s student upsurge and the
anti-Vietnam War movement are always a welcomed contribution to those
interested in mid-20th century U.S. radical history. The collection of
essays that constitute You Say You Want a Revolution: SDS, PL, and
Adventures in Building a Worker-Student Alliance enlarge the historical
lens ??? perhaps, intentionally, perhaps unintentionally ??? by focusing
laser-like on just one of the myriad of groups that emerged during this
time.
Students for a Democratic Society (SDS), was for a short period in
radical history the largest, most vibrant student organization of the
mid-to-late 1960s. PL, or the Progressive Labor Party (PLP), was a
Maoist group that initiated the 1964 May 2nd Movement (M2M) protests
against escalating U.S. involvement in Vietnam; the Worker-Student
Alliance was PLP???s youth front that for a time worked to take over SDS.
You Say You Want a Revolution is full of interesting personal accounts,
anecdotes that throughout the course of the book emerge into a larger
narrative of youthful optimism, activism, excitement and often times
disillusionment with PLP and its undemocratic decision-making structure,
ultra-leftism, and eventual sectarian isolation.
For example, Ellen Israel, a red-diaper baby, was 19 in 1963 when she
helped organize the first of two trips to Cuba. She noted, ???those who
traveled to Cuba,??? in defiance of the State Department, ???came from
different backgrounds and had different motivations for going???[but] many
went on to become progressives, activists and even radicals,??? who helped
to birth the anti-Vietnam War movement. Her story of the trip is worth
briefly recounting not only for what it tells us about the courage and
determination of the activists then bringing attention to the travel ban
to revolutionary Cuba, but also for what it tells us about the aid of
the socialist camp in making the trip possible, as well as the arrogance
of some sections of the U.S. student movement.
After an earlier trip from Canada to Cuba had been canceled, Israel and
the other youth activists were forced to find a more circumscribed route
to the small socialist island. First, they flew to England, then France,
then Prague, where Israel ??? now 20 ??? confronted U.S. officials who had
taken some of the travelers??? passports. She told the agents they didn???t
???have the authority to take valid passports from U.S. citizens traveling
for their own purposes??? and was shocked when they actually gave them
back. Israel???s nerves got the best of her, however, and in a humanizing
aside she recalls that she ???promptly threw up??? after the encounter.
Reunited with the larger group, Israel added, ???Czech officials [then]
took all of us that night to the mountain vacation village of Karlovy
Vary,??? where they relaxed for a few days. The group was then taken back
to Prague, where they boarded a Cuban plane and continued their trip.
While in Cuba the youth group went on a whirlwind tour, meeting with
revolutionary leaders ??? they even played ping-pong with Fidel Castro and
had discussions with Che Guevara ??? and participated in the July 26th
celebrations then taking place, as Cubans celebrated the commemoration
of the rebel attack on the Moncada Barracks in 1953, considered the
start of the Cuban Revolution. While, as Israel put it, ???we
found???widespread support for and participation in the changes that were
being implemented??? since the revolution, some participants were also
frustrated, as getting ???a clear picture of the problems Cubans faced was
hindered by rarely finding leaders who would admit to any shortcomings.???
Reflecting on the discussion with Guevara, the student activists come
off as arrogant. Israel says that Guevara ???was dismissive??? of questions
dealing with African history and the ???forming of worker???s councils
(soviets)??? in Cuba as if students from the U.S. were better-equipped to
address the development of socialism in Cuba. This type of myopic view
is found throughout the various chapter narratives and is illustrative
of the class perspective many of the youth activists drawn to the New
Left then embraced.
In retrospect Israel rightly adds, the ???May 2nd Movement ultimately
suffered from the same sectarianism as PL???s other initiatives??? and ???PL
increasingly prioritized public criticism of those who should have been
their allies ??? the Vietnamese, the Cubans, the African liberation
movements, and, eventually, China.
???Perhaps this is inevitable,??? she added, for a group ???that calls itself
a ???vanguard party??? ??? to feel superior to everybody else, to desperately
try to look ???different??? from other activist groups and movements, and,
above all to be ???correct.?????? Eventually, Israel left PLP, though she
credits ???good people and actions in PLP??? that helped to shape her
political outlook long after the youthful exuberance wore off.
A contributor who participated in the Columbia student strike of 1968,
noted, ???As PL became increasingly isolated from the mass movements???their
anti-intellectual, antitheoretical, and voluntaristic [sic] approach to
rekindling revolutionary activity drove them into a dead end.??? Both
their ???bad policies??? and their ???bureaucratic top-down organization???
together lead to their isolation.
Another contributor added, ???I concluded that PL was an organization
whose attitude was that ???everybody has sold out but you and me, and I???m
not sure about you.??????
Possibly the most important lesson of You Say You Want a Revolution can
be found in this passage by another contributor: ???I also learned how to
not follow PL???s example???In doing political work, I aim to build unity,
not get into sterile ideological arguments [italic in original].???
While there are 23 different and illuminating personal accounts and
anecdotes in You Say You Want a Revolution, they all follow the same
trajectory outlined above: fond memories and relationships, some
nostalgia, youthful, well-intentioned activism coupled with fascinating
individual stories about this or that campaign, protest or rally, and
the eventual disillusionment and a break with PLP.
The editors of this volume should be thanked for bringing these
illuminating and insightful essays to publication. The lessons
encapsulated in this volume may ??? hopefully ??? help other youth activists
avoid the pitfalls and perils that lead PLP to insignificance.
You Say You Want a Revolution: SDS, PL, and Adventures in Building a
Worker-Student Alliance
Edited by John F. Levin and Earl Silbar, 1741 Press, 2019, $18.95, 364 p
Tags:
Analysis
arts and culture
book reviews
Books
CONTRIBUTOR
Tony Pecinovsky
Tony Pecinovsky
???
Tony Pecinovsky is the president of the St. Louis Workers' Education
Society (WES), a 501c3 non-profit organization chartered by the St.
Louis Central Labor Council as a Workers Center. His articles have been
published in the St. Louis Labor Tribune, Alternet, Shelterforce,
Political Affairs, and Z-Magazine, among other publications. He is the
author of "Let Them Tremble: Biographical Interventions Marking 100
Years of the Communist Party, USA," and is available to speak at your
community center, union hall or campus.
RELATED ARTICLES
??IWO: Book traces workers??? efforts to insure themselves against
capitalism???s failures
IWO: Book traces workers??? efforts to insure themselves against
capitalism???s failures
???Fefu and Her Friends???: Forn??s???s feminist odyssey at the Odyssey
???Fefu and Her Friends???: Forn??s???s feminist odyssey at the Odyssey
Outrageous hilarity of ???The Producers??? a critique of capitalist fraud
Outrageous hilarity of ???The Producers??? a critique of capitalist fraud
Comments
0 comments
MOST POPULAR
??Hong Kong protesters have their flags backward
??Hong Kong protesters have their flags backward
New Trump apprenticeship rules are like the fox guarding the henhouse
??New Trump apprenticeship rules are like the fox guarding the henhouse
???Proletarian billionaire??? act wears thin: Trump???s war on workers
?????Proletarian billionaire??? act wears thin: Trump???s war on workers
Take control of the means of news production.?? Become a People's World
sustainer today.
Own It
GET PEOPLE'S WORLD UPDATES
Signup
News
??Views
??About People???s World
??Contact
??Political Affairs Archive
??Mundo Popular Archive
Copyright 2019 Some Rights Reserved.
--
---
George Carlin
??? Tell people there's an invisible man in the sky who created the universe,
and the vast majority will believe you. Tell them the paint is wet, and they
have to touch it to be sure. ???
??? George Carlin