----- Original Message ----- From: Sharon Tzur - sharontzu5@xxxxxxx Subject: ended In response to the following posting: > I prepared a short active / passive verb cloze about the TV show Friends. > However, my question is about number 4. The correct answer is has ended > yet many pupils wrote was ended. I know it's incorrect yet I don't have an > explanation. > Can anyone offer me one that I can pass on to my pupils? BTW, I accepted > ended tho i'll tell them that present perfect is the better answer. >... Although the show 4 ___( end ), its re-runs 5)___ (still enjoy) by >many people I think it is correct to say either the show ended / has ended / or was ended. The show was indeed ended by the producers or investors, or whatever. Ended can be used both as a transitive or intransitive verb (see dictionary entry below), so it can be used in the passive. [intransitive and transitive] if a situation or activity ends, or if someone or something ends it, it finishes or stops [≠ start, begin]: World War II ended in 1945. talks aimed at ending the conflict Furthermore, I did a search on a corpus (www.americancorpus.org ? I highly recommend it. You have to register, but it's free) and I found lots of examples of ending being used transitively, and of "was ended". Investors ended the bear in the black They ended their relationship elder Assad only really warmed to Iran after the Ayatollah Khomeini came to power, ended the Shah' s policy of close ties to the We I've copied some of the corpus results for "was ended". It might come out as a mishmash on the digest version. 1 2009 ACAD ForeignAffairs to power. The Bosnian war, Europe's most bloody since 1945, was ended. A new relationship was forged with China. Relations with Moscow were solidified. 2 2008 FIC Bk:SakeElena time believing that the artistic force within her had died. But all that was ended, as were the seven weeks of growing dread as 13 November approached. // 3 2008 FIC Bk:ExtremeMeasures approved by lawyers back in Washington. # On Wednesday, Nash's session was ended early when he told alHaq that he had spoken to General Abdul Rashid Dostum. 4 2007 SPOK PBS_Newshour division in New York over slavery? Well, of course, slavery was ended in New York State, but it was very much alive in the American South 5 2007 FIC VirginiaQRev forever. When I finally walked out of the hospital, the whole circus was ended, Kirby Smith the only big Reb still in the field. A bald doctor 6 2007 MAG USCatholic up, it was discovered he had quietly left this world. His pilgrimage was ended. In fact pilgrimage has always been a dress rehearsal for dying. What better 7 2007 MAG AmSpect by those earlier statesman-paladins. The proto-Fascist threat posed by Prussian militarism in 1914-18 was ended in part by the eruption onto the Western Front of General Pershing's million-man " 8 2007 ACAD ForeignAffairs (for what turned out to be three years), the urban terror was ended. # Especially if the United States withdraws from Iraq, the odds are good 9 2006 FIC Bridges graced the dome. She also got bad news: the cancer's remission was ended. Not only was her other breast under siege but the cancer was spreading to 10 2006 NEWS Chicago # The touchdown was the first of Bradley's career. His rookie season was ended after seven games with a torn ACL in his right knee, and his role 11 2005 FIC Analog until the pain that radiated up her temples morning, noon, and night was ended. And the doctors merely exchanged their heavy-lidded glances whenever she demanded to know when 12 2005 MAG SportsIll him out at home, so injuring the catcher that, effectively his career was ended. Says Feller, " I was right there and saw it. Whatever they 13 2005 NEWS NewYorkTimes about homosexuality or even sexual intercourse. Or so he did until his career was ended by accusations that he had had sex with female students at the Christian college he 14 2005 ACAD AnthropolQ that found her guilty of electoral malpractice in a prior election. The Emergency was ended in 1977, and its impact on activism in India was terrific: most civil 15 2004 SPOK CNN_Event an evil empire. # More tan any other influence, the Cold War was ended by the perseverance and courage of one man who answered falsehood with truth and overcame 16 2004 SPOK CNN_Event Reagan credit for ending the Cold War. He said, the Cold War was ended by the perseverance of one man. He was more than an historic figure. 17 2004 FIC Bk:RavenWarrior Somehow he had known in his heart that a time of innocence and joy was ended. When Mother's pyre was ashes and she was gone, he told his 18 2004 NEWS USAToday # Many activist Democrats are still outraged by the disputed 2000 election, which was ended in Bush's favor by a 5-4 Supreme Court decision. In a USA TODAY 19 2004 NEWS WashingtonPost right guard to replace Shawn Andrews, the first-round draft choice whose rookie season was ended Sunday by a fractured fibula. Artis Hicks moves in at left guard, where 20 2004 NEWS Atlanta losing to Jeff Davis, and Greater Atlanta Christian's quest for the title was ended by Bacon County. # Buddy Pinkston contributed to this article In 2003-04, for 21 2004 NEWS Denver infidelities and public urination. # The ban was lifted the same week Prohibition was ended, prompting attorney Morris L. Ernst to write at the time, " This week 22 2004 ACAD AmerStudies After a series of slave uprisings throughout the Caribbean, the practice of slavery was ended on this island in the 1840s. In the twentieth century, the descendants of 23 2004 ACAD SexResearch we kept a constant picture interval of 5 seconds. When a picture presentation was ended within this interval, a black background remained until the next picture was presented. 24 2003 MAG SportingNews Then again, we shouldn't be surprised. # Tech's unbeaten season was ended by a West Virginia team that had lost four of its previous six games. 25 2003 NEWS NewYorkTimes extended best-seller list. Ms. Lords, an underage porn performer until her career was ended in 1986 by an F.B.I. bust, is now a happily married 35-year-old actress 26 2002 FIC NewEnglandRev way she understood. It told her to drive -- now, before night was ended-to the sea; to take off her clothes and swim out as far as she 27 2002 MAG Forbes the invention of bricks was unveiled in 1933 -- preformed plaster walls. Thus was ended the huge cost of lath-and-plaster crews that used to finish the insides of buildings. 28 2002 MAG SportingNews with food stamps and unemployment checks and toilet cleaning, a world that nearly was ended a decade ago when he almost quit coaching after no one would hire him, 29 2002 NEWS NewYorkTimes Nations say were seized by the Iraqis during their occupation of Kuwait, which was ended by American-led military action in 1991. # " It includes Kuwaitis, " one 30 2002 NEWS Denver on their palms.' # The seniors in that class, whose season was ended by Oklahoma in the Elite Eight, persevered in unusual circumstances. As freshmen, 31 2002 ACAD LatinAmResRev first place, although many Yucatecans (especially women) supported prohibition, it was ended in no small part because of widespread and mostly male resistance. Second, many 32 2001 SPOK NBC_Dateline On the day this tragic accident occurred, I realized that my career was ended. The buck stops with you. The buck stops with me. 33 2001 SPOK NPR_FreshAir How do these newly released documents revise our understanding of how the missile crisis was ended? Publicly the story that we heard was Khrushchev backed down, he's 34 2001 FIC Bk:ThirdOption three days, cut off from the rest of his government. The siege was ended, thanks to the bold actions of Mitch Rapp and a few select members of 35 2001 MAG BoysLife of grasshoppers invaded the stadium and swarmed the field. The professional baseball season was ended early in September, 1918... by order of the Secretary of war. The 36 2001 MAG Antiques necessary However, despite the policy of open immigration for Europeans, 23 which was ended by the Johnson-Reed Act of 1924, immigrants were not warmly welcomed, as illustrated 37 2001 MAG Prevention the landmark $174 million Diabetes Prevention Program (DPP) -- a study that was ended a year early because the results were so dramatic. Among its 3,224 participants ( 38 2001 NEWS USAToday all will play in college # But as a player whose career at Mississippi was ended by a spinal cord injury so serious he can't even risk contact in a 39 2001 NEWS Atlanta to a single exchange, thus depriving investors of competitive prices. That practice was ended in August 1999. # Three settle SEC charges of insider trading A former paralegal 40 2001 NEWS Chicago star of the documentary " On the Ropes "? Her Golden Gloves career was ended when she was jailed on dubious drug charges, although her parole board allowed her 41 2001 ACAD LatinAmResRev lower Amazon to the present day, although its primacy in the export market was ended by the growth of cacau production in southern Bahia in the late 1800s. The 42 2001 ACAD RehabResrch applied was maintained at the prescribed torque level for five seconds, the trial was ended and the average ankle angle during that time period was displayed. During each trial 43 2000 SPOK NPR_FreshAir that pork, (censored)?' Richard Pryor's performing career was ended by multiple sclerosis, which was first diagnosed in 1986. In 1998, when 44 2000 SPOK CNN_Event the world. The problem with trying to categorize whether or not a war was ended through the intercession of Mother Teresa would be difficult. If there's such 45 2000 FIC FantasySciFi had given up. Just as well. All a waste anyway. It was ended; nothing to be done, no way to make it right. She felt 46 2000 NEWS NewYorkTimes Guslavage reported the information to his superiors, it was ignored and the investigation was ended. # Frustrated, Sergeant Guslavage took his information to the United States attorney in 47 2000 NEWS AssocPress . Time Warner officials said fewer than 20 orders were placed before the offer was ended. # " It was clear that we made a mistake at the local level 48 1999 MAG OutdoorLife the opportunity to fly back to Anchorage to purchase new boots until the season was ended, Ross removed his own boots and handed them to him. They were a 49 1999 MAG Antiques during dinner w vas upraised and served as a sideboard, and when dinner was ended, it was again let down, and shut in with doors opening from the 50 1999 NEWS USAToday when he shoved him. His coach, Craig Hartsburg, whose playing career was ended in 1989 as a result of pain associated with a hit from behind, says 51 1998 SPOK NPR_Morning you think you don't know. Like to really know how it was ended. They don't give us too much in the history books. Slavery 52 1998 NEWS NewYorkTimes vertebrae. # In the book Mr. Reeve describes the life of privilege that was ended by the accident. His father is the writer F. D. Reeve, a professor 53 1998 ACAD LatinAmResRev first experiment with democratic politics, the threeyear period known as el trienio, was ended abruptly by a military coup in 1948. 22 An all-male provisional military junta took over 54 1997 FIC Americas power to love two men at the same time. # The long Revolution was ended. Diego Sauri celebrated it with the caution of a man who no longer waits 55 1997 NEWS NewYorkTimes . # But the fact that the won increased so sharply after the restraint was ended sent a powerful psychological lift throughout Asia, which has been watching the South Korean 56 1997 NEWS USAToday the greatest series in history with three 29-footers. But his 65-meet win streak was ended by Mike Powell, who broke Bob Beamon's 23-year-old mark (29-21/2) by 57 1997 NEWS Houston environment that every other computer had to operate through. # IBM's monopoly was ended by new technology developed by two guys in a garage who created the Apple. 58 1997 ACAD AmerEthnicHis were ferried to the mainland and the history of the Angel Island Immigration Station was ended. One wonders whether the intolerable conditions would have been allowed to go on for 59 1997 ACAD HospitalTopic . The same study found that in 1,000 other cases a patient's life was ended without an explicit, recent request to die. (n14) The study also showed 60 1996 FIC KenyonRev applause, to change the victrola record. But it was when their dance was ended that all the effects of the Dorsets' careful grooming that night would have vanished 61 1996 MAG SportsIll ' lead to 24-21. But an onside kick failed, and a quest was ended. There is no consolation game for the Gators. There was only one acceptable 62 1996 MAG AmHeritage encirclement of the capital city. During the Seven Days' Battles the siege was ended, but more despite Stonewall's participation than because of it. For the only 63 1996 NEWS AssocPress on April 29, but it wasn't until Sept. 21 that free access was ended. # Subscriptions to the Web site cost $ 49 a year for those who 64 1996 ACAD PublicInterest respect to matters incident to dissolution. # James Hayes prevailed. Child support was ended and alimony cut by more than half. A year later, he was back 65 1996 ACAD PerspPolSci government regulatory structure also evolved. The Atomic Energy Commission's monopoly on decisionmaking was ended, and new groups, led by environmentalists, assumed a more prominent role in 66 1996 ACAD WorldAffairs than on Japan. Suddenly and quite unexpectedly, the partition of the country was ended and the Soviet military threat that had swung over the country like the proverbial sword 67 1996 ACAD Environment reached to move toward a complete phaseout of chlorofluorocarbons; ocean disposal of sludge was ended; bans on drift net fishing were imposed; offshore oil exploration was halted; 68 1995 FIC Mov:Braveheart you directed me to report to you the moment the king? s conference was ended. edward So I did! And what was so important about it? PRincess 69 1995 MAG SportsIll was the subject of a gambling investigation by the league, a probe that was ended soon after his retirement with a finding of no wrongdoing. There was speculation that 70 1995 NEWS SanFrancisco Q: You've talked before about returning to the social work approach that was ended in the 1960s by welfare rights advocates who condemned it as too intrusive, and 71 1995 NEWS Houston week, Harrick placed a call to Duke's Mike Krzyzewski, whose season was ended in January by back problems related, in part, to stress. # What 72 1995 NEWS Houston think McNamara should be reminded of that. " # U.S.involvement in the war was ended in 1973, during the administration of President Nixon. By then, McNamara was 73 1995 NEWS Denver silence, when everyone thought about what had been discussed, and when that was ended, the process would start again. The idea was, they'd reach consensus 74 1994 SPOK NPR_Morning in 1979 and worked were never ever forgiven by their colleagues after the strike was ended. To this day, there are umpires in the Major League who go out 75 1994 FIC AmSpect work of art ever struck off by the human brain. When the tape was ended, I stood up and walked to the window of my dressing room. With 76 1994 MAG PopScience ship that launched 17 drones on test flights and photoreconnaissance missions before the program was ended in mid-1971. On all four operational D-21 missions, the film was lost due 77 1993 SPOK PBS_Newshour capital city, north, south, and central. We found the starvation was ended in Somalia. That is no longer the problem. There is plenty of food 78 1993 FIC Bk:FarriersLane Judge Stafford was merely trying to prove once and for all that the matter was ended, and surely no one would have killed him for that. It must be 79 1993 MAG USAToday forces got fed, everybody made a lot of money, and the Depression was ended by 1945. Yet, Robert Taft was, reluctantly, right. Despite the 80 1993 MAG NatlReview my disappointment, and theirs, the problem remained intractable. The program ultimately was ended. # Several years before Livermore began DOVE, the Soviets had started their own 81 1993 NEWS CSMonitor it could be said that the White League ultimately won: In 1876 Reconstruction was ended by a deal to garner Southern electoral votes for Rutherford B. Hayes, who won 82 1993 ACAD ArabStudies hands of local Mamlak Beys. 18 # The despotic rule of the Mamluk Beys was ended by the French invasion of Egypt in 1798. Napoleon, however, failed to 83 1993 ACAD InstrPsych seen on a daily basis. The isolation of the individual classroom and teacher was ended. Teachers commented, " There are more opportunities and avenues to help each other 84 1992 FIC Atlantic for less than two months, and now her life as it had been was ended. The day would come when she would know herself to be a woman of 85 1992 FIC ChicagoRev against Joel's head, but it didn't stop the blood. Practice was ended. The season was ended because most of the kids were too traumatized to play 86 1992 FIC ChicagoRev but it didn't stop the blood. Practice was ended. The season was ended because most of the kids were too traumatized to play. # And nine-year-old Elliot 87 1992 FIC BkSF:Legacy move ments and battle techniques with more than passing interest. The goblin threat was ended, but that was the least of Bruenor Battlehammer's problems. p66 Dinin watched 88 1992 FIC Bk:SongWolf have been cause for celebration among her People. Once her time of month was ended, there would have been a special ritual and blessing for her coming into womanhood 89 1992 FIC Bk:InterviewVampire she had known that they might have to move when Tuomas' current project was ended. The rest of the evening was spent with the two men discussing plans for 90 1992 MAG People for Beatty bashers. What's to snipe at anymore? His perennial adolescence was ended -- blissfully -- by the birth of Kathlyn, going on 4 months. Did 91 1992 MAG SatEvenPost with him. And that meant our once famous relationship as interviewer and subject was ended. # ILLUSTRATION # During the 1984 Olympic Games in Los Angeles, in fact 92 1992 NEWS Atlanta not like I did my last time. " # Bradshaw, whose career was ended by an elbow injury similar to the one that has sidelined Montana, threw his 93 1992 NEWS Chicago and cubed potatoes. Buon appetito and then some! # This particular dinner was ended with a wedge of creme caramel two inches thick and rich enough to make Croesus 94 1992 NEWS Chicago West Coast Conference titles, part of him was ripped apart when the program was ended in 1982. # " It was like you lost something you grew up with 95 1992 ACAD CrossCurrents ? The workers did not rule. What did it matter that capitalist exploitation was ended? Party exploitation remained. Most importantly, so long as its consciousness was imposed 96 1992 ACAD Ethnology which rice could not be pounded or food cooked in oil until the epidemic was ended and an offering had been made in thanks. # By the 1970s, the 97 1992 ACAD SportBehavior indicates the degree of despair sometimes experienced: # I felt my whole life was ended. I felt suicidal at times. I had nothing to live for anymore because 98 1992 ACAD Lancet of technical limitations. In 3 of the remaining 17 women, the recording was ended prematurely (before 90 min) because of passage of the fetus (2 women 99 1992 ACAD ArmedForces mass movements. Between March 1990, when the Communist party's constitutional monopoly was ended, and October 1990, when the new law governing political parties was signed, 100 1991 NEWS NewYorkTimes Eastern in 1986, the alliance unraveled, the union leaders' board membership was ended and labor relations rapidly deteriorated. # Jack Bavis, the leader of the pilots 101 1991 ACAD Ethnology control of much of Asia, some of which went back four centuries, was ended by an Asian nation that had emulated the Western Yours, Sharon Tzur ----------------------------------------------- ** Etni homepage - http://www.etni.org or - http://www.etni.org.il ** ** for help - ask@xxxxxxxx ** ** to post to this list - etni@xxxxxxxxxxxxx ** -----------------------------------------------