Frank, First of all, both cable and broadcasters have access to the Terayon Cherry Picker which can "groom" bitstreams to any bitrate you wish, so it is very easy for cable headends to lower the HD bitrate of broadcasters. Secondly, digital must carry rules state that if a cable company carries a broadcaster in HD, they must carry that broadcaster in the same resolution that they carry other HD services, but not necessarily in the same resolution and/or bitrate the broadcaster is using. So if a cable company squeezes Discovery HD to 12 Mbps, they can squeeze CBS HD to 12 Mbps. From FCC R&O FCC01-22: "From our perspective, the issue of material degradation is about the picture quality the consumer receives and is capable of perceiving and not about the number of bits transmitted by the broadcaster if the difference is not really perceptible to the viewer. Such an interpretation is consistent with the language of the Act, which applies to material degradation, not merely technical changes in the signals." Third, as far as our PBS station goes, we are required to simulcast 75% of our OTA signal on the DTV channel, and at the same time our digital viewers want the PBS HD service. Therefore we have no choice but to multicast both an HD and an SD. John Shutt ----- Original Message ----- From: "Eory Frank-p22212" <Frank.Eory@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> > Which is precisely why I don't believe Cox is doing anything to deteriorate them. Unfortunately, there is no equivalent FCC problem for a local broadcaster who deteriorates the quality of the network HD feed, just so he can multicast an HD and an SD program on his DTV channel. > > -- Frank ---------------------------------------------------------------------- You can UNSUBSCRIBE from the OpenDTV list in two ways: - Using the UNSUBSCRIBE command in your user configuration settings at FreeLists.org - By sending a message to: opendtv-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word unsubscribe in the subject line.