[opendtv] 3-D TV disparities said to cause physical, mental strain
- From: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@xxxxxxxxxx>
- To: "opendtv@xxxxxxxxxxxxx" <opendtv@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Thu, 22 Apr 2010 10:37:03 -0500
Interesting. Maybe that's why so many 3D movies are cartoons.
I can easily describe what makes me queasy in 3D movies. It is the existence of
objects closer to me than the screen, especially when these objects move. Which
Avatar avoided doing.
Bert
-----------------------------------
3-D TV disparities said to cause physical, mental strain
R. Colin Johnson
(04/21/2010 10:16 AM EDT)
URL: http://www.eetimes.com/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=224500108
PORTLAND, Ore. - Visual disparities in 3-D TV images can cause physical strain
in viewers, according to recent research at the University of California at
Berkeley.
While proper viewing conditions can help avoid most problems--dark room,
central seat far from the screen--3-D cinematographers also need to follow
careful rules or risk making people sick, researchers said.
The debate over 3-D TV heated up earlier this week when Samsung issued a
warning about possible health effects.
Even if the physical strains of 3-D are avoided, other disparities can cause
mental strain akin to vertigo, according to other investigators at the
University of Washington. "If [cinematographers] confined 3-D to animations,
then there wouldn't be a problem [since] the brain doesn't have the same
expectations about cartoons," said Aris Silzars, founder of Northern Lights, a
display technology consultancy (Sammamish, Wash.)
For the emerging crop of 3-D movies that incorporate real-world scenery, movie
makers have one extra job beyond those of previous animations: Minimizing the
so-called vergence-accommodation conflict.
The conflict arises from the fact that 3-D displays often cause distortions in
perceived 3-D structure compared with the percepts of the real scenes the
displays depict.
"The only thing we have any data on is what we call the vergence-accommodation
conflict, which our lab has shown really does cause fatigue, discomfort, eye
strain and headache in some cases," said professor Martin Banks, who led the
research into 3-D eye strain at the UC-Berkeley, which was funded by the
National Institutes of Health.
According to Banks, when viewers direct their eyes at nearby objects or scenes,
their gaze converges. When they gaze into the distance they, diverge, or what
optometrists call "vergence." Conversely, focusing the eye muscles to bring
something into sharp focus is called "accommodation."
In the real world, vergence and accommodation are synched to the same distance,
but in the world of 3-D stereoscopic glasses decouple the two, forcing the
brain to cope with a disparity between the vergence and accommodation distances.
"Normally the distance to which you converge your eye and accommodate your
focus are the same, so understandably your brain has coupled these together,"
Banks said. "The problem is a stereo or 3-D display breaks this coupling, and
the reason why is that the disparity between the images that are being
presented to the two eyes might specify something behind the screen or in front
of the screen--and in those two cases you have to converge your eyes to a
different distance than the screen, but you still have to accommodate the
screen because that is where the light comes from."
The Berkeley researchers have performed two studies that reached the same
conclusion: 3-D TV induces a vergence-accommodation disparity in the brain that
manifests itself in a statistically significant number of people as fatigue,
discomfort, eye strain and headaches. So far, test subjects have been between
18 and 30, but Banks plans to test 50-year-olds to determine whether they are
immune to the vergence-accommodation conflict, as he suspects, since older eyes
do not focus as well.
Banks recommends two solutions to minimize eye fatigue and other symptoms:
Viewers should sit very far from a 3-D TV screen as they would in a theater.
The farther from the screen, the smaller the difference between the convergence
and the accommodation distances, Banks said.
The second is to shoot 3-D videos so that action is located at the front of the
screen, not off one side or projecting out of the screen into a crowd. By
minimizing the vergence-accommodation disparity, the possibility of fatigue and
other symptoms will recede in most people, according to Banks.
"The better 3-D movies, like Avatar and Pixar's 'Up' are clearly trying to
minimize this conflict with the way they do the cinematography," said Banks.
Even if the theater experience is duplicated in the home, not all of the
potential problems associated with 3-D TV will be resolved, according to
University of Washington professor Robert Patterson. Patterson and Silzars
presented their results at the 2009 Society of Information Display. According
to the researchers, three other cognitive disparities can cause fatigue in
addition to vergence-accommodation: binocular disparity, linear-perspective
disparity and texture perspective disparity.
For instance, if a 3-D scene depicts a football player running the length of
the field, depth has to be compressed into a few yards by the cinematographer
to prevent too much parallax, causing viewers to see double-image ghosting.
Linear perspective (geometric angles) and the texture perspective (distant
objects that are less detailed) signal the brain that the distance traveled was
100 yards, thereby creating cognitive disparities.
"The reason why high-level cue conflict leads to discomfort in immersive stereo
displays is that the intuitive reasoning system is attempting to make reasoned
sense out of this incoming, conflicted perceptual information," Patterson and
Silzars wrote.
These higher-level cues create conflicts in the brain that causes mental strain
in addition to the physical eye strain of the vergence-accommodation disparity,
they added, which becomes intolerable over time, resulting in a confused state
of mind akin to vertigo.
"When you take away cues, you create in the brain what is called the 'doll
house' effect. The scene can be very precisely constructed, but it does not
look real--it looks like a doll house--because your brain is saying that its
missing cues that are always present when viewing real scenes," said Silzars.
"It creates a vision-to-brain conflict that can make you feel nauseous and
dizzy or worse."
Worse still, according to Patterson and Silzars, is that the closer a set of
cues comes to matching reality, the more discomfort viewers experience. That
means the problem could get worse as cinematographers attempt to make 3-D
experiences even more realistic. One solution, according to Silzars, would be
to confine 3-D content to animations since the brain does not expect cartoons
to contain the same realism as normal video or film.
"In Avatar for instance, the scenes that were shot with real backgrounds were
less convincing than the animated scenes because the brain has lower
expectations for animations," said Silzars.
All materials on this site Copyright (c) 2010 TechInsights, a Division of
United Business Media LLC. All rights reserved.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You can UNSUBSCRIBE from the OpenDTV list in two ways:
- Using the UNSUBSCRIBE command in your user configuration settings at
FreeLists.org
- By sending a message to: opendtv-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word
unsubscribe in the subject line.
Other related posts: