[projectaon] Re: Project Aon's license violation at Sourceforge? (PalmOS reader project)

  • From: "Thomas Wolmer" <angantyr@xxxxxxxxx>
  • To: projectaon@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
  • Date: Sun, 11 Jun 2006 11:53:14 +0200

2006/6/11, Javier Fernández-Sanguino Peña <jfs@xxxxxxxxxxxx>:


Hi there,

I've recently stumbled upon this Sourceforge project:
http://sourceforge.net/projects/lonewolf-palm
This is the project description:

Lone Wolf PalmOS Reader [1]

   PalmOS reader and character manager for Joe Dever's Lone Wolf series
   as provided by Project Aon.

This project was started november 2004 and has only released files in
december 2004.  Admins are jinxidoru (M. Paul Bailey, sourceforge member
since march 2002) and zaedyn (Josh Menke, member since january 2006). It
claims that the license its contents are distributed is the GPL.

However, this project distributes the following files:
[ http://sourceforge.net/project/showfiles.php?group_id=123741 ]

- Palm OS reader (lonewolf-0.1.prc)
- Lone Wolf books converted to PDB for use in the reader:
lw-books_1-5.zip  lw-books_6-12.zip lw-books_13-15.zip

From what I understand, all those zip files are in violation of the Project
Aon license, as they are the XML books converted to PDB and distributed
outside of Project Aon.

Is the project aware of this? Should steps be taken to have those zip files
removed from Sourceforge ?

Damnit, is this up at Sourceforge too...

This is a strange story. Michael Paul Bailey contacted us long ago -
http://www.freelists.org/archives/projectaon/09-2004/msg00061.html -
saying he was developing a PalmOS reader, and I am pretty sure we
replied back to him. I created a board at the PA forum for it anyway:
http://projectaon.proboards30.com/index.cgi?board=palmosreader

Then later he put up the reader and the converted books at his
personal website, jinxidoru.com, saying that he knew it was
technically illegal to have the books there, but that he had tried to
contact us and never heard back. After this was reported to us, last
spring I think, I tried to email him, twice, but never heard back.
Later his website became unaccessible. Google still has it cached, but
it seems that no new content was added after December 2004.

Now I see that he does have two blogs that he's actively writing to,
and he's also posted to some PHP forums, so he is apparently still
around.

--
Thomas

Other related posts: