On May 10, 2004, at 4:35 PM, Manfredi, Albert E wrote: > Any idiot with TV Guide on his lap and a remote control has been > able to customize his own prime time for decades. And with a VCR, > or two, even more so. The VCR(s) made conflicts and schedules a > thing of the past. I just don't get this PVR hype. > > Bert > Bert, it's never been as simple as you describe it. You still had to manually program the VCR, make sure the tape was properly positioned so as to not tape over something else you wanted to get around to watching, fast forward or rewind to get to the show you wanted to see (and usually guess which it was, fast forward or rewind), hope that the show wasn't in a different time slot this week, or maybe a two hour special. And then, of course, you were limited to the length of the tape in the VCR, maybe eight hours at SLP speed. And if you came home ten minutes into Seinfeld you had to wait for the show to end if you wanted to watch the whole thing from the beginning. It was just a lot of things to keep track of, and the VCR makers never found a way to make it very easy for the average user. Get a new VCR and you had to re-learn the system. I missed many a recording because the tape ran out, or I forgot the leave the VCR in the proper mode (usually "off") so that it would record. Kind of like saying "I don't understand what the big deal is about this Google thing...libraries have always had card catalogs!" In comparison, a PVR is a joy to use. Tell it what shows you like, or even what KINDS of shows you like, and it starts collecting them, no matter when they are on. Come home, watch what you want, when you want, pause live TV if you choose (or rewind to see if that was really what you thought you saw on the Super Bowl) fly past commercials. After time-shifting with a VCR for many years I can tell you having a PVR is a vastly superior experience. In fact, when I bought my Tivo I completely underestimated how much it would transform my viewing habits. I never sit down and just surf through channels, because I've always got a collection of shows that I like available to me on the Tivo. It's empowering. I am a much more efficient TV viewer. People who have Tivo absolutely love their Tivo. I've never seen a home appliance get the kind of rave reviews from people that Tivo gets. And most of them say something along the lines of, "Tivo changed my life." Sounds like silly hype, but I can say from experience that switching to a PVR is a huge boost in taking control of your viewing habits (and that of my five year old son!) and it is a big quality of life improvement. I'm looking forward to the next logical step, having a Tivo-like device which acts as a home media server for the whole house. TV shows, MP3 collection, all served from one central location and available on every set in the house. Dave Bittner - Pixel Workshop Inc. www.pixelworkshop.com 410.381.8555 ---------------------------------------------------------------------- You can UNSUBSCRIBE from the OpenDTV list in two ways: - Using the UNSUBSCRIBE command in your user configuration settings at FreeLists.org - By sending a message to: opendtv-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word unsubscribe in the subject line.