Hi all, I don't live in an ivory tower. ( just a small house in a small yishuv near the shrinking Kinneret) so I know just how hard English teachers work !!(Really hard) Now, I want to add my 2 cents to the whole hullabaloo!! I took part in the pilot and subsequently began to teach a few of the Infusing HOTS into Literature courses and I did this mainly as I believe that this "new" way is better For one it allows those students who are NON test oriented to excel. (and I was told this by my pupils who did the pilot and loved it !!) As it stands today our pupils have to take two external English tests, so if the teacher chooses the Log, it caters to some of the kids who have gotten lost in the shuffle over the years. (and shouldn't we be catering to as many of our students learning styles as we can ?) . THERE are a myriad of reasons not to like the program and to be apprehensive of not being ready to begin implementing it and concerned about how much work it will be . However, there is ONE main reason to embrace it whole-heartedly with it's flaws and that is simply because the students (OUR students) will benefit from it !! From my experience , having already implemented it (both during the pilot and now with my 10th graders) most of the students really like it !! They found the lessons much more interesting and so did I . WE did not just do writing ( although it was part of it) We also did enactments/ role plays/ group work/ graphic organizers in pairs, class discussions etc.. So I say , put aside your fears and try it. Is it perfect .?? * NO *.. But it will be "a work in progress" and the sooner you get involved the sooner you can put in your input !! But mostly , . do it because it makes teaching much more creative and interesting for our students. ( for us too !!) and making them think and know that they are thinking isn't a bad thing.. I apologize that I won't be at ETAI (Dafka this year) but am more than willing to talk (online / by phone) to anyone who wants to talk to me. Wishing us all a bit of rest and a happy , safe and relaxing summer vacation !! Aviva An optimist and a thinker !! "It must be remembered that the purpose of education is not to fill the minds of students with facts?it is to teach them to think.? Robert M. Hutchins Aviva Shapiro- 052-4501830 ----------------------------------------------- ** Etni homepage - http://www.etni.org or - http://www.etni.org.il ** ** for help - ask@xxxxxxxx ** ** to post to this list - etni@xxxxxxxxxxxxx ** -----------------------------------------------