[opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change
- From: "Manfredi, Albert E" <albert.e.manfredi@xxxxxxxxxx>
- To: "opendtv@xxxxxxxxxxxxx" <opendtv@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Fri, 7 Feb 2014 00:16:56 +0000
Craig Birkmaier wrote:
> The white spaces gobbled up nearly half the available spectrum to
> protect the other half.
That's absurd, Craig. You get lost in uninformed, vague generalities. The
existence of guard bands is not a conspiracy against competition. With analog
TV especially, the Europeans have the same situation as we did, with respect to
locally unused frequency bands. You need these to provide interference-free,
continuous coverage. (And, in fact, local low power stations can and do use
those guard bands, in intervening markets.)
The "national broadcast footprint" you mention doesn't change anything, unless
you're somehow conflating this spectrum policy issue with the theoretical
possibility, only with DTV, of creating nationwide SFNs. In fact, this
theoretical possibility couldn't be exploited, in Europe, because DVB-T1 is not
*in practice* capable of providing this. To even approach huge nationwide SFNs,
DVB-T1 would have to dial down to very low spectral efficiency. We went through
all of this many, many times.
> The problem is that the government is doing nothing to break up
> these oligopolies, when it is clear that technology is no longer
> an is due with respect to bypassing the content and distribution
> oligopolies.
Even that isn't true. Isn't the government redefining what constitutes an MVPD
service, to allow OTT sites to compete against the entrenched TV providers?
Yes. Didn't the government force DTV receivers to be embedded in TV sets? Yes.
Both of these increased competition. It doesn't matter whether a lot of the new
channels show old movies. The government is not forcing them to only show old
movies. How they will compete is changing day by day.
> The most notable change is that another government enabled oligopoly,
> the telcos, are starting to compete with cable and DBS for TV
> services,
Verizon FiOS competing against Cox and Comcast, when providing MPEG-2 TS
broadcast channels, is merely a small transitional sideshow. Haven't you heard
about Internet TV? Get past this MVPD obsession, Craig.
> What is more important is that other industries had to work around
> the barriers to competition that these standards created,
The only alternative, to make you happy, would have been free use of the IP.
Yes, sometimes that works too. But paying royalties for IP is not "a barrier to
competition," but rather "the cost of doing business."
> Compare this to the ATSC standard, which was already outdated by
> the time most consumers bought a HDTV. I would note that Bert
> rightfully pointed out the critical role that standards play in
> enabling the Internet transport of bits. We asked the FCC to do
> the same with DTV - i.e. just standardize the modulation and
> transport layers.
Craig continues to misunderstand what it takes to create a useful
communications standard. Thank goodness the FCC had a clearer understanding.
The Internet is used only to "carry bits," as Craig says. But applications that
run over the Internet must agree on encoding standards. So, even in the early
days of the Internet, users on each end had to agree how characters, numerals,
entire documents, spreadsheets, graphics, etc., were going to be encoded. Or
they wouldn't be able to communicate. The Internet Protocols didn't care, but
the end users did. At first, this was a mess. IT WAS VERY COMMON TO RECEIVE
FILES OVER THE INTERNET THAT YOU COULDN'T DECODE. De-facto standards were not
yet widespread, except at best ASCII text. Eventually, de-facto standards such
as Lotus 123, WordPerfect, Adobe Acrobat, MS Word, emerged. (Wow! Just like
Flash Player! What a concept!)
*But*, with DTV, the FCC had to create an APPLICATION, Craig, not just the
pipe. The FCC had to create a standard way that EVERYONE could buy a TV and
expect it to work. The ATSC had to standardize all the way up to the
application layer.
And even then, Craig thought the ATSC had developed a "point solution." Not
true, but in his defense, few people back then understood then what layered
protocol standards were. In fact, right from the start, the ATSC added SD
formats and, with publication of A/90, all manner of other possibilities opened
up.
I'm afraid that your misconceptions lead you to erroneous conclusions.
Bert
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You can UNSUBSCRIBE from the OpenDTV list in two ways:
- Using the UNSUBSCRIBE command in your user configuration settings at
FreeLists.org
- By sending a message to: opendtv-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word
unsubscribe in the subject line.
Other related posts:
- » [opendtv] Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Mark Schubin
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Mark Schubin
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Mark Schubin
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Mark Schubin
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change - Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Albert Manfredi
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Manfredi, Albert E
- » [opendtv] Re: Digital Trends: ESPN may pull its finger out of the Internet-TV dam, unleash a flood of change- Craig Birkmaier