Jarrett Vance wrote: > Consider for a second that your a huge fan of CSI. > Now sometimes you won't be able to watch the show > live so you may record it and watch it later. Your > penalty for not watching the show live is that you > really wanted to know why Grissom was in jail but > you didn't find out as soon as you could have. > Your reward for not watching the show live is that > you get no commercial interruptions. This reasoning is premised on the idea that people must have instant gratification. Which is why, by your argument, not watching a show like CSI live deserves a reward. (Parenthetically, to me, being forced to comply with broadcasters schedules is the punishment that deserves the reward. So your analysis would not work in my case.) On the other side of the coin, I can easily argue that free OTA TV's only chance of being competitive with the umbillical services *is* the increased use of recording. So recording cannot be viewed by the broadcasters as being "bad." If broadcasters made effective use of their time on the air, an OTA user with recorder would have way more content to watch than time to watch it. But broadcasters can't be expected to transmit good stuff outside prime time if they figure it will get stolen outright. Just as cable companies wouldn't waste time on premium services if people could buy boxes that bypass the encryption without paying the cable company. Fair use will not go to hell if fast forward is allowed but not ad skipping. And ad writers I believe can make this work very well for themselves too. Bert ---------------------------------------------------------------------- You can UNSUBSCRIBE from the OpenDTV list in two ways: - Using the UNSUBSCRIBE command in your user configuration settings at FreeLists.org - By sending a message to: opendtv-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word unsubscribe in the subject line.